11 ms·
How to organize a study group, book club, online group or event
- spectre256 8y agoFor those who aren't familiar with her, Stephanie has been an extremely helpful and resourceful voice on Twitter (and clearly, her blog) on a whole range of topics: - Founding and running a small company - Working in/with/around the video game industry (good and bad) - Health, work life balance - Identifying and reducing bias in all sorts of situations (work, social, online, etc) - Tasty, healthy food to cook with vegetables She's well worth a follow: https://twitter.com/sehurlburt https://twitter.com/sehurlburt
- emit_time 8y ago> She's well worth a follow Seconded.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bluejellybean 8y agoVery helpful article, I especially like the idea of creating a code of conduct as a way to set the setting.
- FakeComments 8y agoA formal code of conduct in a small group points to premature politicization, and is generally a red flag. Examples like this make me seriously question the post: > One of my favorite creative examples is signs I saw at one event in the women's bathrooms about instructions on how to report sexual harassment, including words you could use to discretely report it while the harasser was still bothering you (like ordering certain drinks). This sounds like someone who enjoys being boss and LARPing social dynamics, not a genuine solution to social problems, much less advice that makes small groups function better. This is infantilizing to women, and portrays them as pseudo-children who can’t even manage to directly tell someone else they need help. If Stephanie’s contention is that women really can’t manage to simply tell someone they need help, without special club room signs and coded language, then maybe we should fix that — it sounds deeply unhealthy and unreflective of the women I know. But if she’s not seriously contending that, her suggestions have the seriousness of LARP scenery ideas.
- rexpop 8y agoYou probably oppose codes of conduct in general, because you do not think your conduct should be held to a standard, personally.
- greenhatman 8y agoI oppose it for small events. You don't have a code of conduct for a party or a gathering of friends. It's just assumed that if you're not a positive influence in the group you're probably not getting invited to the next gathering. To me, it just feels too impersonal. Everyone is different, and most people like to be treated differently in some ways. People communicate this through facial expressions and body language. It just feels more organic without too many formal rules.
- rexpop 8y ago> To me, it just feels too impersonal. This is a relatable criticism. I think you're right that we lose some sense of the carefree, unfettered relating when we pause to articulate our codes of conduct. I, too, yearn for such liberated communities, and cherish them when available. However, I don't think we can, as a society, afford to make assumptions. What's not explicit often exists, as I've tried to illustrate in sibling comments, implicitly and politics—ie the distribution of power amongst individuals—always exist. They're better when they're explicit. Even between only two people! Every relationship should stand on the basis of explicit boundaries and expectations. It's often said that asking and checking such boundaries "kills the mood," and I think you're making a similar argument. The rebuttal is that relationships are much safer, and therefore deeper and valuable, when boundaries are explicit. They're worth it, every time, from 2 individuals to 7 billion. Explicating boundaries might even be a fundamental necessity of relating, in an informative, topological sense.
- FakeComments 8y agoI think codes of conduct become relevant somewhere between 100 and 1,000 people, organizationally. Around the point you’re transitioning to more political structuring because simpler mechanisms break down.
- bluejellybean 8y agoI'll reply to myself because of the general sentiment of the comments seem to be about the safe space aspect. I read this article in a completely different way, I read it as a way to set a tone for the rest of the events within a new group. The examples she uses suite her groups and how she wants her groups to interact. If on the other hand one wants to actively dis-encourage a safe place(it's just an example, I am not advocating this), one could explicitly setup their code of conduct to do so. If nobody shows up, okay so be it, but if people do show up, congratulations you have now built a culture around those specific ideals. Sure maybe this is a little much for a group of 3-5 people, but if one wants a large group with a specific style of culture to form, setting some simple guardrails does seem advantageous. Perhaps 'code of conduct' is to authoritarian but setting group ideals from the get go does not strike me as necessarily bad.
- vvpan 8y agoThe idea that you should define a code of conduct first just sounds awful. The best small gatherings are organic and informal. This just (I'll use a word from somebody else in the thread) politicizes the whole thing. In other words, if I am looking to join a group of 3-4 people and they have a code of conduct already defined - I am just not going to come, simple as that. In general the author seems to be into formalizing things. Organizing events is a wonderful skill, but if you look like you are overthinking you'd be a excluding a broad swath of people to whom formality is the opposite of friendly warm relationships they are looking for. For example: Every Wednesday I attend a board game night at somebody's house. I know everybody there, but we are not necessarily all friends. Both sexes and a range of ages are represented. If one day the hosts came up with a formal set of rules I think Wednesday game night would be over.
- winningcontinue 8y agointeresting. Organizing isn't free and even if it's just a casual group without an explicit code of conduct, people don't just show up for no reason. They look for other people and see who else is showing up. There is an organizer. Whether it's the venue owner, who will tell you they're not going to do a meeting because of a holiday, or a core group of regular attendees who rely on each other to show up and get a signal of whether or not there will be enough of a quorum to launch a game/discussion. Sometimes people on the outside will show up not knowing, and find out that the meeting has been canceled. It's only when the rules become too onerous and exclusionary that people decide not to join in. In a board game group, the rules are kind of reinforced through people who don't show up on time not being able to be in a game and wait. In a study group or book club it can get annoying as hell catching up the person up to speed so they don't recover something that they missed out on because of lateness.
- Todd 8y agoShe said under Code of Conduct, "This was something I didn't always have when first organizing groups years ago, and I learned over time why it's necessary." I was curious about that and hoped that she would elaborate.
- 8y ago
- keiferski 8y agoThese days, I keep it simple with my small and short-lived groups and opt for a "benevolent dictator" model-- all violations reported to me, I can kick anyone out for any reason. Whenever possible, inconvenience the people with money and make it convenient for those in poorer areas. — Or, How to organize an event in which you are surrounded only by likeminded people and immediately kick out anyone that thinks differently. I hope within my lifetime we return to a interpersonal communication model of: “I’m a person, you’re a person’ sometimes we disagree or misunderstand each other, but we both will try our best.” The current trend of over legislating (by actual law or lists of rules) is becoming quite childish, in the sense that we are no longer treating people like adults.
- meruru 8y agoArticle is just a blank page for me, even after turning on JS and disabling tracking protection. Luckily it's archived: https://archive.fo/Lxeqy https://archive.fo/Lxeqy
- black-tea 8y agoI read this thinking it might be interesting because I'm organising a book club at work. But it's more "how to make a safe space". No. My book club will not be a safe space, it is open to everyone who reads the book.
- afarrell 8y agoIncluding someone who interrupts and talks over everyone else and doesn’t change in response to feedback?
- llao 8y agoOf course not, just like my forum would not be open for people who post flame-bait like yours. Behaving like a decent human being is an implicit, obvious rule.
- slyall 8y ago" I'm sorry why are you kicking me out? I read the book and I'm not doing anything wrong! I guess I'm talking a bit more than some other people but they are just quiet and I'm an outgoing guy. " "Are you seriously implying that I'm not a decent human being because I talk a little more than Bob? "
- cf498 8y agoWhich can be answered with a simple "get lost". edit: Since some people seem to disagree, why not? I fail to see how its any more complicated then those two words. You put in the effort to organize the bookclub, you have the prerogative to say who can participate. If you dont like that make your own bookclub. Forums have thrived on this concept for decades and it only got complicated once they became business enterprises. Maybe to phrase it more broadly outside of the organization aspect and for general social interaction. You dont have a right to be part of a social group or go to a certain party. If I dont like you I likely wont spend time with you.
- 8y ago
- afarrell 8y ago> didn't speak from their own experience using "I" statements This feels like it is trying to teach a social skill through the medium of a code of conduct. Is this successful at teaching? I think one thing thats challenging is that social groups genuinely do run more smoothly when people have more social skills. But spreading this knowledge is hard because: 1) Lots of people feel condescended-to when you offer them the advice of how to learn social skills. (See: Stephanie Hurlburt’s writing about unsolicited advice, Lots of people on this thread expressing that they feel like this post fails to treat them as adults) 2) Lots of people (like me) find Its hard to realize when there even is a particular skill to learn and from there, hard to find guidance on how to learn it. People are reluctant to offer advice to group #2 because it upsets group #1. People in group #1 get condescended-to all the time by people trying to help out group #2.
- maxheadroom 8y agoI was totally behind the premise until she referenced her Code of Conduct[0] and I saw this tucked-away in it: "I do reserve the right to boot anyone out for any reason" That, to me, comes across as conducive to an authoritarian atmosphere and not a community atmosphere. You can dress it however you wish but having a Code of Conduct and then saying it matters not, when you arbitrarily feel like it, is the antithesis of the entire premise of fostering a community atmosphere, in the first place, yeah? Why not just be honest and have that single statement and be done with it? Afer all, you are the be-all and end-all of the group, it's code, the decision-making, and subsequent results, yeah? [0] - https://pastebin.com/6kA93uPV https://pastebin.com/6kA93uPV
- sokoloff 8y agoI see that single sentence as the default starting point for any small group. The preceding sentences serve as clarification and additional guidance/assurance of intent, but if in a small group (book club) setting you wish to explicitly disclaim the ability to boot anyone for any reason, you end up having to create a lengthy and still-gameable set of rules, itself a book-authoring exercise.
- maxheadroom 8y ago>I see that single sentence as the default starting point for any small group. This is a valid point of view, in the sense of coming from the perspective of group ownership. "I own this thing and I decide what happens in it or will protect it or what happens to it or what direction it goes in or etc. ad infinum." I think this is an entirely different notion than a community perspective, in which no one seeks flat-out ownership or determination (by and solely derived from themselves). Whilst this latter posit might be hard (if not nigh impossible) to implement in small groups, I think it comes down to the approach: The dynamic changes determined upon if its of the individual's interest or if its of the group's interest. This is because its recognised that the individual ego doesn't foster community growth - however subdued it might come across - because (in an actual community, such as here in HN) the group dynamic isn't interested in things like individual ownership and explicit individual control of anything. For example, we do not come here (to HN) because one voice posts or one narrative predominantly prevails over another. In fact, some of us come here in lieu of other sites (such as /r/) precisely because we recognise that only being exposed to a single narrative that aligns with 'x' isn't conducive to any growth, in either the community or the individual. In other words, I don't have to agree with you for us to exchange ideas and/or learn and grown from our differing perspectives. Couple that with the fact that your or my viewpoint isn't going to get the entire discussion thrown under the bus (as long as we're being civil about it). >The preceding sentences serve as clarification and additional guidance/assurance of intent, but if in a small group (book club) setting you wish to explicitly disclaim the ability to boot anyone for any reason, you end up having to create a lengthy and still-gameable set of rules, itself a book-authoring exercise. True but you're muddying the waters. The single sentence should be first and the rest should follow subsequently because that single sentence explicit infers that it can happen, even if the person in question is the embodiment of the Code of Conduct. All that has to happen is that the organiser has a valid reason (to themselves) to justify booting the person. The community, as it were, can do nothing about it and it's tucked away in the Code of Conduct that they've all agreed to, yeah? So, whilst it may come across as a surprise and/or the community might feel the exact opposite about what's happened, you start delineating the whole precept between individual wants versus group wants. This is when you get off-shoot splinter groups because they don't agree with what 'x' group leader[s] did. It's a story as old as time and we keep repeating it because we fall into the same traps over and over and over and over and over again. Put succinctly: If the individual supercedes the group (no matter who it is but, in this case, it's almost always the organiser), then what you have isn't a community in the true sense of the word. You've formed a group around an authoritative figure under the auspices of it being a community. Take a look at any communities around the internet and you'll see the individual dies-away (in the authoritative sense) when true community is the first and foremost priority. Ubuntu's Code of Conduct[0] would be a good example of this. Their Appeals Process for IRC[1] also demonstrates that they're concerned with the community perspective over the individual. "Did Skyler eject you because you made in typo in English? Well, that's not quite fair..." If you want to foster community (proper-like), you should start fostering the community for the sake of the community (and not the sake of the individual) from the onset. Suffice to say, we will probably not agree on this and I'm sorry for typing a novel in response. I'll shut up, now. :) [0] - https://www.ubuntu.com/community/code-of-conduct https://www.ubuntu.com/community/code-of-conduct [1] - https://wiki.ubuntu.com/IRC/AppealProcess https://wiki.ubuntu.com/IRC/AppealProcess
- nickjj 8y agoSome of my favorite meetups were the 2600 meetups from the 1990s (in NYC). Just a bunch of people meeting up in a pre-defined public space with no real agenda but at the same time everyone there had similar interests. Basically it was a bunch of casual conversations with people who like the same things as you do. No pressure or grand event. Just a bunch of people sitting at separate tables or standing around in small groups for as little or long as you want. Nowadays most tech meetups kind of suck. I used to goto more meetups but it's always the same thing. A few minutes to mingle with people before it "starts" and then you sit in silence while you listen to 1-2 hours of presentations that feel like advertisements. Then things end with "mingle time" but by this point everyone is drained by the presentations and half of the people leave because it's already 8-9pm and some people have ~2 hour commutes to get home.
- parliament32 8y ago> 1. code of conduct Yeah... hard pass. If the first thing I'm doing is defining a code of conduct for a few (close) people with shared interests, something is very wrong with the kind of friends I keep.