3 ms·
> Assange gave Manning a CD to boot from on the target computer, containing tools to copy the protected password data. what's wrong with this? > * Assange rec
by baby 8y ago
> Assange gave Manning a CD to boot from on the target computer, containing tools to copy the protected password data.
what's wrong with this?
> * Assange received a copy of the password hashes from Manning, and attempted to crack them.
Assange tried to find the pre-image of a hash. There's nothing criminal about that either.
- baseballdork 8y ago> what's wrong with this? It's conspiracy. > Assange tried to find the pre-image of a hash. There's nothing criminal about that either. That's also conspiracy. You can't take these two acts out of context. They were done with the intent of stealing and disseminating classified information which is illegal.
- leereeves 8y agoYes, intent matters, and there's a reasonable case that what he did was illegal. But because intent matters, if Assange's intent was to reveal information that the public should know, then what he did shouldn't be illegal.
- hjk05 8y agoInforming the public of situations where the government is killing innoscent people is illegal, no big suprice. But that doesn’t mean we have to support extradition to North Korea of every journalist who publishes the truth about that horrible regime. And by the same merit you don’t have to support the American regime going after Assange for exposing their murders of innoscent.
- Veen 8y agoIs your question “what’s wrong with a non-citizen supplying the means for a member of the military to access and share sensitive data”? I should have thought it obvious what is wrong with that. There’s nothing intrinsically wrong with briskly thrusting a knife back and forth. But if there’s a person stood in front of you and you intend to kill them, the moral and legal context changes. Context and intent matter.