4 ms·
I would like that system, but unfortunately most of our fellow citizens would end up broke come tax time. Most people simply say "I can spend until my bank acc
by jedberg 8y ago
I would like that system, but unfortunately most of our fellow citizens would end up broke come tax time. Most people simply say "I can spend until my bank account is empty".
That's why most people choose impound accounts when they get a mortgage. Because they literally can not budget money for the bi-annual property tax bill, so they have the bank take the money every month.
It's also why teachers are offered a 10 check plan or 12 check plan. They get the same money, but most of them choose the 12 check plan, just so they don't have to remember to save money to live in the summer.
That's why the banks offer those "save your pennies" plans. Every time you make a debt card charge, they round up to the nearest dollar and then put the rest in a savings account for you. Because people are that bad at budgeting.
Can you imagine most of the people you know having the ability to set aside 20% of their check each month and not spending it ever?
- mises 8y agoI get this, and also that it's to help prevent the sticker shock of taxes that can lead to serious backlash. With that said, America is not supposed to be a place where the Nanny State must step in to manage people's lives for them simply because they can't do it themselves. I and my fellow citizens should not have to lose money simply because others choose to waste money. I like the comment lotsofpulp made below: "The solution to people’s inability to save is not for the government to hold their money hostage."
- war1025 8y agoThe government doesn't hold anyone's money hostage. You are free to adjust your W-4 withholdings any time you want. They even have an online calculator to estimate your tax burden and set your withholding properly.
- mises 8y agoYes they do, because there is still employer withholding. Almost 75% of Americans had too much withheld: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/01/30-million-americans-are-not-withholding-enough-pay-for-taxes.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/01/30-million-americans-are-not... And if you don't believe me on the reducing-sticker-shock part, here's a quote from the Treasury: "it... greatly reduced the taxpayer's awareness of the amount of tax being collected, i.e. it reduced the transparency of the tax, which made it easier to raise taxes in the future." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_withholding_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_withholding_in_the_United_... It is indeed a very underhanded way to con citizens into putting up with stupidly high taxes. Oh, and for what it's worth, it hits lower incomes harder because they are less likely to hire tax advisors, fancy accountants, etc. to make sense of it all for them. Maybe we would end up with lower taxes on our poorest, too, if they realized how much they were being robbed.
- war1025 8y agoFor the record, I make good income for the area, which isn't amazing, and also have three kids. I had no federal tax burden this year and was in fact reimbursed $1800 of surplus child tax credit. So I find it hard to believe the poor are paying too much in taxes if they are anywhere near the same boat as me.
- ben0x539 8y ago> Most people simply say "I can spend until my bank account is empty". I don't think this comes down to just individual discipline/budgeting either. If you rejiggled things to that people who live paycheck to paycheck suddenly have non-zero amounts of money in their accounts for most of the year, I bet you'd suddenly see cost-of-living prices/rent adjust upwards so that they're living paycheck to paycheck again, except then they're fucked when taxes are due. Landlords etc aren't gonna leave money on the table.
- everybodyknows 8y agoIRS actually has a documented policy on the "12-check plan": https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/409a_presentation.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/409a_presentation.pdf Wonder how many teachers understand that the net financial effect amounts to a zero-interest loan from themselves back to the school district?
- mac01021 8y agoThat example teacher is very well compensated.