4 ms·
The argument on the interwebs about how many holes a straw has shows that there is no generally accepted usable definition of "hole". You can have lots of exam
by ColinWright 8y ago
The argument on the interwebs about how many holes a straw has shows that there is no generally accepted usable definition of "hole". You can have lots of examples, and describe each, but the fact that I give a well-known, common object to a bunch of people and ask "How many holes are there in this?" and proceed to get a range of answers shows that there really isn't a working, usable, generally accepted definition.
I suspect we've got different definitions of the word "definition".
- lisper 8y agoThat may be, but it remains a fact that every competent speaker of English knows what it means to "dig a hole in the ground", and the result of that process is not a topological hole. The problem is that topologists chose the wrong word. Consider: Bob digs a hole in the U.S. and Alice digs a hole in China. How many holes are there as a result? Clearly there are two. Now suppose they dig deep enough that their holes meet. Now how many holes are there? Answer: zero. What you have now is a tunnel.
- ColinWright 8y agoSo there are no holes in a straw - it's a tunnel. This just points out that "normal English usage" is inconsistent and impossible to use in any kind of technical context. As soon as you examine one of the most common senses in which we use the word "hole" we find that there are complexities. The study starts with "What do we mean by hole?" and the rabbit warren is entered. What follows is the investigation of the unavoidable consequences of things you thought were obvious. You said: > The problem with being topologically pedantic about this is that it is at odds with the actual English definition .. I said: > ... what you're saying is a problem is actually an opportunity. You're agreeing that there really is no consistent, usable definition of the common usage of "hole", and that people just have to know what it means. I'm pointing out that the technical approach gives us a tool whereby we can start to map usable definitions fro the technical study back into the real usage of language. It's not a problem, it's an opportunity. Perhaps this is an opportunity to look beyond the statistic treatment of language and get mappings to "meanings", whatever they are. Perhaps the Word2Vec idea can be taken further. The technical world is full of words that don't "mean the same thing" as when used in a non-technical sense. Function, Object, Module, Expression, Constant, Scope, these are all words that have a technical meaning in a technical environment that break down when you get into the non-technical world. Criticising the content of the video for starting with a non-technical sense of "hole" and trying to make technical sense of it seems odd.
- lisper 8y ago> So there are no holes in a straw - it's a tunnel. Well, it's more like a tunnel than a hole, but it's not quite a tunnel either. I can touch the outside of a straw. It's not clear that I can touch the outside of a (proper) tunnel. But yes, topological holes are a lot more like tunnels (in the ground) than they are like holes (in the ground). But on the other hand, topological holes are like holes in your socks. Socks are a really good example because no one refers to the inside of a sock as a "hole". If a sock is in good repair it has no holes despite the fact that it superficially resembles a floppy cup. > It's not a problem, it's an opportunity. In this case I would call it a missed opportunity. And that's a problem (IMHO). The missed opportunity is to really talk about the subtlety and malleability of natural language and how mathematics can make things precise, and why this is desirable. Instead it comes across as a geek being smug about knowing the "right answer" to brain teaser because topology.
- Retra 8y agoOr take a sphere and poke a hole in it. Topologist says there are no holes, because now it is a disk. But wow else would you describe poking a hole in a sphere?
- lisper 8y agoEven that is based on the tacit assumption that the sphere you are poking a hole in is a two-dimensional manifold and not a solid. If you "poke a hole" in a solid sphere (which is what you actually do when you dig a hole in the ground) you haven't change anything from a topological point of view.
- ColinWright 8y agoSphere, not ball. A sphere is inherently a two dimensional manifold with no edges, two sides, and no embedded loops that are homotopically not a point. It's an idealised "shell". However ... I'm trying to understand your points here, but it's almost like you're saying that the things mathematicians do have no value as they stand, and they should be doing something else. That might not be what you mean, but reading your comments as a whole, that's the impression I'm getting. Much of what you say is true, but seems to be going off on that tangent. Mathematicians, in these sorts of circumstances, take abstract things that are, in some senses, approximations of something from reality, and then examine those abstract things to see what they can find out about them. They are approximations, and sometimes the results aren't applicable, but often they are. This video is a case in point. We look at how we can model the straw, and see what the word "hole" might mean in that model, then map it back to reality to see what answer that gives us. But your comments all seem to be saying: But that's not relevant to how we use language, and so you're neither getting the "right" answer, nor doing anything fundamentally useful. So based on that reading of your comments, I'm not sure I have anything further to add.
- lisper 8y ago> it's almost like you're saying that the things mathematicians do have no value as they stand I have no idea how I could have left you with that impression. I'm talking about pedagogy and rhetoric, not math. I opened with: "The problem with being topologically pedantic..." I honestly don't know how I could possibly have made it any plainer.
- snowwrestler 8y agoTry handing an inflated ballon or unbroken sheet of copier paper to the same people and ask them how many holes it has; I doubt you'll find much disagreement between the answers. This implies that there is a definition of some kind. English word definitions are probably better analogized as overlapping probability distributions, than as mutually exclusive sets of discrete values.
- ColinWright 8y agoNow give a straw to those same people and ask how many holes there are and you'll get a range of answer, which implies that whatever you think is the definition, it's not working. Just because you get agreement over some small range of examples, that doesn't then mean that it's a wide-ranging, usable definition. Start sphere that has a small hole in the top and ask how many holes there are, you'll get the answer "One". Now make the hole a little bigger, then a little bigger, then a little bigger again. Keep going, and eventually you can turn this into a disk, or a shallow bowl, and now the (natural language) answer is "Zero". When did it change? People will disagree because there really is no "proper" usable consistent definition. Not in natural language. And with regards a probability distribution - are you going to say that at some point the object I've described above has a half a hole? That's actually an intriguing prospect, to say "What's the probability that this thing has a hole?" Probabilistic linguistics. Interesting.
- snowwrestler 8y agoNames come from people, so the probability being distributed is the probability that you'll get a given name from a given person for a given thing. Take your sphere-to-disk example. The bigger the hole gets, the less likely it is that a given person will describe it as a hole. But at various points you'll get spikes where most people say "hole," "bowl," "disk," etc. Personally I think it's silly to take this as proof that the definition of hole "isn't working". Probability distributions are good enough for quantum mechanics and fluid dynamics, but not language? Also look around: people communicate about holes productively (i.e. to accomplish work) all the time, so obviously the definition is working just fine under many conditions. Language is one of those things that works way better in practice than in theory.
- mcphage 8y ago> proceed to get a range of answers shows that there really isn't a working, usable, generally accepted definition > I suspect we've got different definitions of the word "definition". You probably do. If you think of definition as some mathematical description that strictly delineates what does and what does not qualify... that's not how human language definitions—or even human words—work.