13 ms·
> ... if you start with a closed 2D surface (like a sphere), you have to pierce it twice to make a straw. But in topology, the first 'hole' you add isn't a 'hol
by ColinWright 8y ago
> ... if you start with a closed 2D surface (like a sphere), you have to pierce it twice to make a straw. But in topology, the first 'hole' you add isn't a 'hole' at all ...
That's from one point of view, as the video says. From another point of view it is a hole. From that point of view, making a "straw" from a sphere requires two holes. The question the video then goes on to ask is whether that point of view is "the best" one. The conclusion is that it probably isn't the most useful - in this context.
But in other contexts, if I have a sphere - genuinely a two dimensional object, all the points (x,y,z) in R^3 satisfying x^2+y^2+z^2=1, when I then punch a hole in it, it has a hole. It's now homeomorphically a disk, but it's a sphere with a hole in it. In this context, for this purpose.
So I think you are overly-condensing the video and removing important points.