3 ms·
It's not hard for writers to connect to employers. It's hard for studios to connect to competent writers without wading through a tidal wave of utter dross. Fr
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
It's not hard for writers to connect to employers. It's hard for studios to connect to competent writers without wading through a tidal wave of utter dross.
From the studio POV, an agented writer is likely to be at least reasonably competent. From the writer POV, an agent is likely to be at least a reasonably competent negotiator and have direct industry contacts.
The idea is that the studio gets people who can do the job without having to read thousands, perhaps tens of thousands, of terrible scripts from wannabes. Agents try to talk up writer fees and include standard extras because writers have no clue what their services are worth to a studio, and many don't understand the finer points of studio contract law.
When the system works, everyone benefits. Of course it doesn't always work, and writers get screwed in all kinds of creative ways. But agenting means that on balance they still do better than they would going up against Gigantic Media MegaCorp Studio on their own.
Now, streaming has created an explosion in TV programming, and some agents are setting themselves up as production houses rather than as talent managers.
This changes the balance of power and makes agents more like an employer with a vested interest in cutting a deal than a representative with an interest in cutting a good deal for their client.
Hence the (off-screen) drama.
- mooreds 8y ago> It's not hard for writers to connect to employers. It's hard for studios to connect to competent writers without wading through a tidal wave of utter dross. So agents are a filter, like tech recruiters, essentially.
- SEJeff 8y agoThis is pretty much spot on, but they also represent your name / brand on an ongoing basis.
- ThrowawayR2 8y ago> Of course it doesn't always work, and writers get screwed in all kinds of creative ways. But agenting means that on balance they still do better than they would going up against Gigantic Media MegaCorp Studio on their own. Interesting concept. In the tech industry, I'd be much more okay paying an agent or agency directly to represent me than being in a union, since I'd be able to vote with my feet (by switching agencies) and my money if I feel a particular agency is not properly representing my interests. Unfortunately, here the writers are being represented by both an agency and a union and are therefore being double-billed, so to speak.
- sethhochberg 8y agoPlus, as an employee, I negotiate salary and benefits with confidence but always keeping in mind that I'm negotiating against someone who I have to work with once we sign the contracts - you can only push your position so strongly while maintaining a comfortable working relationship for the long term, you can say "its just business" all you want but people on the other side still get their feathers ruffled. In some sense, the agent or recruiter here is also being paid to be the asshole - everyone expects it of them, hardball is part of the deal, the employee being hired can just sit back and shrug and say "hey, my agent is tough to deal with sometimes, but they're good at their job" and reduce confrontation with their new boss. On top of that the agent has perspective on market rate for a role that goes well beyond what you could hope to gather in Glassdoor, by asking friends, etc. If it were commonplace in tech, I'd absolutely hire an agent on my behalf if I were doing gig work.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> It's hard for studios to connect to competent writers without wading through a tidal wave of utter dross Looks like there’s an opportunity for the Writer’s Guild, with the help of a few technologists, to create an internal peer-review system. (Ideally, where reviewers are blind to the writer’s identity.)
- specialist 8y agoDoes the entertainment industry use standardized contracts, term sheets, whatever it's called? Or is everything negotiated case by case? From the outside looking in, it seems that one of Y Combinator's core innovations (contributions) is normalizing that stuff, giving everyone the same deal. Reduces friction, increases certainty. Thereby improving the market.
- Mindwipe 8y agoThe unions provide standard negotiated templates usually, which many contracts are based on, but with significant amounts of bespoking on a case by case on top of them for any major talent.