7 ms·
It feels like this reinforces this feeling I've had about money. Those who work with the money always seem to carve out a larger slice for themselves, often in
by Waterluvian 8y ago
It feels like this reinforces this feeling I've had about money. Those who work with the money always seem to carve out a larger slice for themselves, often in increasingly clever ways. It's a one directional battle where those who don't work with the money are always on the defensive.
I'm thinking a lot about managers and sales at the engineering firms I've worked at in the past. They get to see the numbers coming in, the salaries of everyone, and have a lot more say over who gets paid what. They've got the data which is power. The talent who actually produce the product are in the dark.
- Kapura 8y agoThis is the labour/capital struggle that your socialist friends talk about. In capitalism, labour produces the products, but capital still has control. Which is why it's so important for things like unions to exist. Without a union, writers wouldn't have any way to fight back against packaging.
- AlexB138 8y ago> This is the labour/capital struggle that your socialist friends talk about. In capitalism, labour produces the products, but capital still has control. In what sense do Sales people own the means of production and exploit engineers? They're simply closer to the flow of money and able to take advantage of information asymmetry. This is a different phenomenon, and a more interesting one in my opinion. It's part of the difference between those who make a thing, and those who do supporting business functions that happen to put them in an advantageous position.
- Waterluvian 8y ago"information asymmetry". I knew there was a term for what I was trying to describe. Thanks.
- 0815test 8y agoNo, it's specifically labor of superintendence which has control - as distinguished from both capital and "wage" labor. Equity owners often get screwed just as badly because of these control issues, which is one reason why firms might want to resort to issuing debt, and the root reason why issuing equity (as in, title to a share of profits) is in turn bundled with ceding some amount of control over the firm.
- duxup 8y agoIn a previous career I worked on a support team at a company where support contracts brought in a ton of money. Support was part of what the company sold as a product as much as the product itself. It brought in a lot of money even during slow economic times. However, over time the sales team gained more and more influence. Since their compensation for support contracts was seen as a given they wanted to really focus on sales. Eventually they came up with the great idea to offer support for "free". A product with free support became fairly popular because of the price. Sales increased but support tools and staff did not because there was just no new support money. Worse yet workload skyrocketed because sales took off ... among price conscious customers who were pretty terrible users and demanded a great deal of support time. It didn't help that the product itself was often sold as something it wasn't. Eventually the layoffs in support started because "support just wasn't bringing in enough money to justify the head count". The folks with visibility to the money did fine in the short term despite even undermining the company's long term income, everyone else not so much.
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoSometimes the business thinks they know but the delivery team, generally the smartest folks IN the business are ignored at their peril.
- duxup 8y agoAt that role in support I cultivated some good relationships with engineering and others. But even there I ran into some "the customer is doing it wrong" kind of feedback from engineering. Nothing was better than getting everyone on a conference call with the customer (I prepped the engineering team so no surprises) and letting engineering talk to them in a situation that they're a bit less likely to use that line of reasoning. Amazing how quickly things were done after that ;) Yeah sometimes the folks on the ground know how it really works as opposed to those who don't see it day to day.
- paulie_a 8y agoI firmly believe that all developers spend on going time fielding customer calls.
- jadbox 8y agoThis is one of the reasons why I believe in rev-share employee co-ops. The power dynamics are greatly equalized: everyone gets to see the profit and everyone knows how much others are getting paid. Sure, there's uncomfortable and challenging situations to still work through, but the benefit of having more distributed worker ownership and transparency is a value worth pursuing.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoI believe in them as well, but... but where are they? With all the benefits of hard working people and without stupid, greedy managers standing in their way, co-ops should be literally everywhere!
- burger_moon 8y agoI can't name any tech companies who do it, but I've seen in traditional businesses (the kind that don't lose VC money for years). They just aren't really the companies you're going to read about on here or cnbc.
- PButtNutter 8y agoSome tech companies kinda do it by paying employees in stock. The highest paid employee at Amazon only makes $150,000 cash, while the company creates shares of stock to fund the rest of their compensation. Those are actual shares that get taxes as income, not options. Since Amazon doesn't participate in stock buy-backs, like most tech companies do, most of the salaries are actually funded by stock holders in the dilution of their shares.
- vijayr02 8y agoIs that really the case? Let's say Amazon paid all salaries in cash. Also, for simplicity let's says employees view cash and stock compensation as perfect substitutes. Then the addition compensation has to be funded by Amazon - if it won't do so from cash from operations or debt, it has to come from raising equity: Which in effect is the same as paying employees in stock.
- gumby 8y ago> They've got the data which is power. The talent who actually produce the product are in the dark. There's no reason you have to run your company this way. IN fact making salaries public within the company should very much improve things. If they are fair then what's there to hide, and if they are unfair, why is that so? And if they look unfair but aren't, then some explanation can't hurt.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agomaking salaries public within the company should very much improve things Is it how you run your company?
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoIt doesn't happen more often because people are petty and over value their contribution.
- gumby 8y agoThen this kind of pay ignorance presumably leads to unhappiness in those people too, which sounds bad all around.
- gumby 8y agoYes I have always run my companies this way. Even in a bootstrapped company people always knew how many months of cash we had on hand (sometimes scarily few!). And sometimes there were salary injustices and people pointed them out. Typically when someone thought a salary was wrong they wouldn't complain publicly, but ask "why is the marketing VP getting so much?" And we could show salary surveys, what the VP does, etc. This kind of attitude helps keep a company together. You know about the common attitude of engineers shitting on sales and marketing as morons or the marketing folks with contempt for the engineers who "have no imagination?" I've never had a company like that.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y ago
- pmoriarty 8y ago"I'm thinking a lot about managers and sales at the engineering firms I've worked at in the past. They get to see the numbers coming in, the salaries of everyone, and have a lot more say over who gets paid what. They've got the data which is power. The talent who actually produce the product are in the dark." I've long thought that it might be educational to work as a recruiter for a few months. That way I'd get access to what is effectively an honest, accurate salary survey, not the highly suspect self-reported numbers you see on various websites.
- csa 8y agoOverkill, imho. You can find folks on HN who have worked in that industry, and they will share this info with you. It’s almost a red pill experience.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI thought about that too. Seeing a lot of salary negotiations on different levels must give you an edge for your own negotiation.
- seem_2211 8y agoAs a recruiter, yes, this is exactly what we do. My speciality is salespeople, and if you show me a LinkedIn page I can tell you (within about a $5k range) how much someone is making.
- PowerfulWizard 8y agoThat's interesting, what in particular is the most revealing?
- seem_2211 8y agoThere isn’t really any one thing it’s more a function of a number of things (market they sell to, deal size, quota, is it software only, is it new vs existing biz) and then asking about performance.
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoReal estate agents too. 6%? Why don't they get paid hourly like other contractors?
- Waterluvian 8y agoWhat!!? My agent made 2% on a 500k - 1M home last month.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoIt is typically 6%, split between buyer's and seller's agent.
- apathy 8y agoUsually it’s 1% to 3% on each side of the sale. I sure as hell didn’t like paying $45000 to the agents but we would have listed (and sold) the house for $50000 less if not for our agent’s prodding. So in the end we cleared an additional $5000 by not getting nervous and accepting her advice. We thought the market was cooling down too much to support a price on the high end of the range. We were wrong. It sold in one week.
- citrablue 8y agoThe problem here is that who knows if your listing price was optimal. I know some real estate agents who would argue that in a hot market, you should list for significantly less in order to create a bidding war. It doesn't make sense to compare this outcome to what you -- an amateur -- would have done.
- mysterypie 8y agoBut isn't it usually the exact opposite of your experience? That is, the agent will happily encourage you to sell it at a lower price because she wants her commission now, rather than a very slightly greater commission 6 months from now? As an example, suppose your house could sell for $750,000 immediately with you paying a 6% commission of $45,000. Or, suppose the same house could sell in 6 months (after a lot of showings) for $800,000 with you paying $48,000 in commission. The $50,000 extra you'd make on the sale is really big for you. But the extra $3000 the agent makes for months of extra work and waiting around is nothing. She'd rather take her $45,000 after selling it cheap after 1 week and then move on to sell another house. Isn't that the normal dynamic? EDIT: I've heard that you can write a listing contract so that the agent's fee is tiered. So, for example, they'd get 1% if they sold it for $500k because even a "for sale" sign written in crayon in front of the house would sell it, but then 6% on the amount between $500k and $750k, and a juicy 18% or whatever on the price above $750k. But does anybody actually do this?
- gist 8y ago> The talent who actually produce the product are in the dark. So you think the 'talent' is able to be 'talent' without the sales and management? Do you know how many people (in entertainment) are where they are not solely because of talent but because of sales and marketing? Ditto for software. You think that the google guys (Larry & Serge) would be able to make it on their own strictly on their own 'talent'? All that matters is Wozniak, Jobs the 'con-nive-er' didn't matter? And I am not saying this in a 'well without the Janitor we wouldn't..' type of way either. Sales, marketing and management is a very important part of the process. > seem to carve out a larger slice for themselves, often in increasingly clever ways Yet you don't think that the same cleverness leads to sales at the company and/or other benefits?
- int_19h 8y agoIt's not about who can't do without whom. It's about who creates most of the value that is ultimately delivered to the consumer. No matter how you slice it, no scheme in which the intermediaries make orders of magnitude more than the producers is fair, and especially so when intermediaries can do this because they are operating from a position of power. (Unless you adopt a radically unconventional definition of "fair", such as "whatever a laissez-faire market produces is fair by definition".)
- burtonator 8y ago> Those who work with the money always seem to carve out a larger slice for themselves Not trying to be cynical or snarky here at all but it's kind of an 'of course' moment I've had on this a long time ago. If you're a software engineer or hacker you tend to have the best laptops, best home network, best smart phone setup, etc. Look at how inept on tech your friends are compared to you. They're smart at whatever they're doing. If they're a firefighter they're probably amazing but when it comes to tech they're incompetent or at least naive. Same thing for money... if ALL you do is work with money you're going to be amazing at it.... This is why I want to work with money. Unfortunately, this is how the world is just setup.
- maxxxxx 8y agoTotally agree. I always think that negotiating a salary as a company accountant must be pretty easy because you know exactly what’s going on. That’s why I don’t understand that a lot of employees are against salary transparency. Maybe they think they got a great deal but from my experience most people who think they got a good deal in reality don’t.
- djakjxnanjak 8y agoI can look at the salaries of the companies that advertise salary transparency and know for sure that I’m getting a better deal than I would get there.
- maxxxxx 8y agoDo you know how you compare within your company? That’s probably a better benchmark.
- djakjxnanjak 8y agoSeems average based on what people are posting on Blind.
- walshemj 8y agoHmm when I worked for BT the accountants had their own sweetheart deal on pay progression - the STEM professionals not so much.
- maxxxxx 8y agoInformation is power. In my company the financial guys also have a very regular promotion schedule compared to R&D where you are pretty much stuck after a few years.
- tomohawk 8y agoHonest people are rare. An honest person will do the right thing even when they think no one else is watching, and even when they believe they will never be caught. That, of course, brings up the question of what the "right thing" is. In a society with no moral absolutes, what is the right thing? Who is to say that a greedy agent is not a good person, as compared to an honest agent?