16 ms·
It's not so much that it breaks productivity, it's annoying on a simpler level. You are doing productive thing x. Person A sends you a hello message and your c
by mrguyorama 8y ago
It's not so much that it breaks productivity, it's annoying on a simpler level.
You are doing productive thing x. Person A sends you a hello message and your chat app pings you. You go to look at chat and now you are staring at an empty chat window for the minute or more it takes for person A to actually ask what they could have sent already.
I honestly think you can treat "conversations" in a chat program as more like email. Sure, some of the time you can get a conversation going, but if you don't already have a continuous conversation going then create a fully self contained message
- ergothus 8y ago> now you are staring at an empty chat window for the minute or more it takes Worse, you're trying to figure out if it's worth refilling your short term memory with the things you just dropped when you checked on the chat. It's not a minute of boredom, it's a minute of having too much in your brain but you're uncertain if it's worth it to stop the effort or not.
- voidhorse 8y agoThis critique doesn't really make sense. No matter how the person asks their question your flow is going to be interrupted the moment you open your chat apps. If the person says hello then asks a question a minute later your flow is broken. If the person asks the question right away now you're answering the question and your flow is, just as likely, broken. As far as flow interruptions are concerned, it's not the fault of the person asking a question but rather the invasive design or reliance on chat, or your own patterns of chat consumption. The real solution to this problem isn't to impose some kind of rule that people should stop spending an extra minute to be polite, but rather that we should all adopt conscious consumption patterns around chat, i.e. setting aside time each day when you focus strictly on work and ignore chats for x hours (your role permitting). Rather than letting the chat notifications dictate when you attend to them, you should dictate when you attend to chat notifications, and if it means breaking some important flow you have going the chat can probably wait. Edit: I suppose the only exception to this is when the question is something that requires a one word answer and can be answered instantaneously, but if that's the case that's probably a sign you have larger communication problems in that things that are easily answerable are in the heads of workers and not stored in some uniformly accessible place.
- sonofaplum 8y agoThis critique doesn't really make sense. `sleep 60` Because one interruption takes x amount of time to deal with and the other interruption takes x + 60 seconds of staring at a chat window that FEELS like 3 times as long
- voidhorse 8y agoThat’s a fair point, but the original complaint was about the break in thought flow or activity immersion. That’s going to occur whether you sleep 60 or sleep 10. That happens the moment you decide to interrupt your focus by looking at the chat. Of course there are some roles that require immediate attention to chat messages when they come in, for example if you’re on call or something, but for the majority of jobs you don’t have to answer right away. Instead of focusing on our own consumption patterns and lack of discipline/restraint we like to blame others because it’s easier—if you’re in the middle of something wait to get to the chat until you’ve reached a good break point. This is why it’s also good to adopt rules of use for different communications tech, e.g. x chat channel is to be avoided except for emergencies, or DMs are assumed to be casual and important stuff must be relegated to certain channels etc etc.
- ravitation 8y agoI honestly do not understand why anyone would just stare at a blank chat window for a minute (or more) instead of switching back to what they were doing (or, in most(?) cases, just looking at a different screen). It's similar one of your sibling comments which compares a chat message to a person walking up and saying "hello"... They are absolutely not equivalent; it's perfectly alright to not immediately respond to every message you get (or even only giving it a bit of your attention), even if they are not emails. I wonder if this is a generational thing...
- randrews 8y agoWell, because the second you look back to the other window and remember what you were doing, it's just going to ding again with whatever their actual question was.
- ravitation 8y agoI must just be better at multitasking than most... It doesn't really take a lot of my focus to respond to an arbitrary greeting with an equally arbitrary greeting... Certainly not to the point where it's going to take minutes for me to get back to what I was doing.
- gowld 8y agoThat's great if your work doesn't require concentration.
- ravitation 8y agoI certainly don't think devaluing someone's work (especially when you have no idea what it is) is a useful direction to take this conversation. I was essentially conceding that clearly others are not as able to switch contexts easily.
- fossuser 8y agoYeah agreed - it's more irritating than anything else. It anecdotally also seems like the people that do this also tend to be more annoying and slower at typing in general, but maybe I've just conflated the two.