3 ms·
Here's another paper: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7677819 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7677819 "Tal's Formula is the Trapezoidal Rule" A rebuttal
by kenjackson 16y ago
Here's another paper:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7677819 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7677819
"Tal's Formula is the Trapezoidal Rule"
A rebuttal doesn't get much blunter than that.
- mbm 16y agoIt's intriguing that the author's two-page rebuttal is among her 'selected publications'. http://www.sph.unc.edu/nciph/jane_monaco_1990_1984.html http://www.sph.unc.edu/nciph/jane_monaco_1990_1984.html
- carbocation 16y agoThe two page rebuttal that was written by Jane Monaco is among Jane Monaco's selected publications. (You linked us to Jane Monaco's page, not Mary Tai's.)
- ehsanul 16y agoThat is what the GP thought was interesting. So do I.
- carbocation 16y agoI see; I misunderstood the intent of the link.
- pmorici 16y agoJust a guess but they only have three total so selected might mean "all" publications and even then the one you cite only has 2 authors instead of 10 and Jane's name is listed first. It's that something that is important to post graduate students?
- hugh3 16y agoCertainly in most scientific fields it would be unusual to be an assistant professor with a career stretching back to the early 90s and have a publication list that sparse, but I suppose things must be different in medicine?
- wladimir 16y agoThis does happen a lot in science. Between fields and even within a field, for example a biologist discovers a handy 'new' data structure that is useful for storing DNA samples. Which is simply a basic binary tree. As the reviewers of a biology paper are usually biologists and not computer scientists, they might not notice the obvious. Similarly, within computer science I've seen cases like this as well. A researcher in scientific visualization built an awesome visualization algorithm based on a 'new' data structure. Then it turned out this data structure was already discovered in the 90's by a theoretical computer scientist. In neither of my cases it undermined the underlying research, it's basically just a missing reference. It's inherent in science that some things are rediscovered once in a while and it is very hard to follow articles from a completely other field. However, something as blatant as rediscovering integration reviewers from each field should have noticed....