4 ms·
I think Michael Williams (third comment) has the right idea when he says "I’m sure you can find plenty of physicists saying spectacularly naive things about med
by brianlash 16y ago
I think Michael Williams (third comment) has the right idea when he says "I’m sure you can find plenty of physicists saying spectacularly naive things about medicine...". Of course OP's discovery is amusing - even alarming - but approaching it with an air of condescension won't do much to advance either field.
- frisco 16y agoCalculus is taught in high school and expected to be basic knowledge for any physician, even if they don't use it often, and especially so for researchers. Calculus is fair game on their admissions exam, even! On the other hand, there's never an expectation that physicists know medicine.
- brianlash 16y agoOf course. I never claimed we don't have an egregious error on our hands.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Leptosiphon 16y agoCalculus is not taught to everyone in high school. Many students only make it as far as precalculus and many more, even if they take calculus in high school do not learn integration. At the college level, many biology students do not take calculus. As far as calculus being a requirement for entrance into med school, in many cases I am afraid you are incorrect. http://www.cse.emory.edu/sciencenet/additional_math_reqs.pdf http://www.cse.emory.edu/sciencenet/additional_math_reqs.pdf Most pre-meds do not have the time in their undergraduate careers to take a two semester series in calculus, especially if they need to also take remedial courses such as precalculus first, and many do.
- mbreese 16y agoCalculus, per se, isn't a requirement, but physics is covered pretty heavily on the MCAT. And last I checked, you needed calculus for college level physics.
- carbocation 16y agoCalculus-based physics is not tested on the MCAT. Or, at least, no calculus is required for the physics portion of the exam.
- realitygrill 16y agoTo my utter shock - I thought it'd be one of the last bulwarks against premed memorization. When I learned otherwise, it was sad to think that those students who flocked to non-calc physics (and floundered; the classes are of course curved) really would have a good shot at medical school.
- Leptosiphon 16y agoMost universities have a physics sequence that does not require physics. A major reason this sequence exists, at least at the university that employs me, is pre-med students. Also, physics is not "covered heavily" on the MCAT.
- dannyb 16y agoThere's a big difference between "saying spectacularly naive things" and publishing in a supposedly respectable journal. Plus, the guy deserves an academic weggie for naming a method after himself...
- fluidcruft 16y agoDid someone mention Kurzweil and his army of computer science yes men?