3 ms·
On a side note, the creators of YouTube ought to [at least informally] unionize. There's no reason Adam Neely should be getting copyright "strikes" for explaini
by exabrial 8y ago
On a side note, the creators of YouTube ought to [at least informally] unionize. There's no reason Adam Neely should be getting copyright "strikes" for explaining music to the masses, or Cody's Lab should be forced to take down videos on mining with explosives [on his family's ranch]. YouTube needs to have a hotline for problem solving for their most profitable content providers, and until the creators collectively hit the pocket book, they'll face these disruptive yet easily solvable problems.
- prolepunk 8y agoThis is an interesting idea. The nature of the work of youtubers parallels with the work of Hollywood actors, someone might want to organize Screen Actors Guild for youtube creators.
- criley2 8y agoMCN's are basically the private version of this. Content creators join MCN's "Multi-Channel Networks" with the idea that the MCN will handle some of the more administrative and legal tasks while the content creators focus on content. MCN's try to help with the copyright striking and often do have a direct line to youtube due to their size and importance.
- eropple 8y agoI haven't paid attention to this in a few years, but haven't MCNs gone through a pretty bad stretch? I seem to recall a lot of people leaving theirs (sometimes acrimoniously) because they weren't handling those administrative/copyright issues.
- busterarm 8y agoExcept MCNs sit as a middleman to you getting paid. The Defy Media debacle taught everyone a hard lesson. For those unaware, Defy Media went bust and had taken out substantial loans to operate. A large number of big creators are still unpaid while Defy Media's creditors carve up the company's assets. All those creators are going to get left unpaid.
- criley2 8y agoFair enough, but to bring this case up without mentioning mandatory union dues and the costs of unionization feels disingenuous. Unions very much are a middle man between labor and management, and the collective bargaining agreement that this potential Creators Union would sign would hamstring a creators freedom in this space pretty significantly as well. Is what it is, both choices have positives and negatives from my perspective.
- busterarm 8y agoYeah, but at least unions don't take your entire paycheck up front before giving you your cut.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoAs a tangent to your tangent, seeing a name like Adam Neely, whose videos I've been watching all week, even though I know nothing about jazz or playing music, really strikes me as the magic of YouTube. It's being able to watch talents you'd never normally be interested in, but who prove to be genuinely entertaining, even if you don't know what a quarter note from a crotchet, and it's amazing to realize these people are gaining fame in such a huge market, despite being incredibly niche.
- mistermann 8y ago> whose videos I've been watching all week, even though I know nothing about jazz or playing music, really strikes me as the magic of YouTube 100% agree about that being the magic of YouTube, and it's something I feel that most people just don't get. There is so much amazing and incredibly professionally produced content, as good or far better than what you get on TV, on YouTube that simply would never, ever have made it to TV or movies. And not just quality content, but someone in a third world country with a relatively tiny budget, can capture a huge audience which can show the masses what "others"[1] are really like. I happen to believe YouTube could go a long way to healing some of the growing divisions we're experiencing in modern society. Well, that is if you could actually get individual people to develop a little curiosity, and get YouTube to put a little genuine effort into discoverability and curation of videos, and get politicians to not want to keep people dumb and divided. So it will probably remain yet another lost opportunity to make the world a better place, like so many other opportunities we've squandered. [1] http://www.otheringandbelonging.org/the-problem-of-othering/ http://www.otheringandbelonging.org/the-problem-of-othering/
- Mirioron 8y agoYouTubers won't unionize. There's no way that's going to happen after what MCNs did. People aren't going to trust new organizations coming along promising the same things.