4 ms·
Looking at the transcripts behind the indictment, Assange gave assistance to Manning to log in as a different user to protect his identity as a source. It's st
by monocasa 8y ago
Looking at the transcripts behind the indictment, Assange gave assistance to Manning to log in as a different user to protect his identity as a source.
It's standard for journalists to give material support to their sources in whistleblower circumstances in order to help protect their identity.
- ardy42 8y ago> It's standard for journalists to give material support to their sources in whistleblower circumstances in order to help protect their identity. I don't think it's standard for journalists to give material support for the criminal acts of their sources. For instance: what if Assange had assisted Manning by giving him a gun so he could kill someone who'd discovered that he had blown the whistle, in order to help protect his identity? I think the key question is, did Assange help Manning commit any crimes, or did he merely report the information resulted from Manning's un-assisted crimes?
- dictum 8y agoWhile your metaphor is merely intended as a comparison of aiding a crime, it's made hazier by the introduction of a crime of a grisly nature (murder) committed directly (the source pulls the trigger; it is not a murder caused by a third party without the knowledge of the source and the journalist) A better comparison would be a journalist buying a wrench that can pry open a certain box, or conversely, a lock that makes it very hard to open a certain box.
- _rpd 8y ago> Assange gave assistance to Manning to log in as a different user to protect his identity as a source. Except that the "different user" was an admin account that had the needed permissions to access the data Manning wanted to upload to wikileaks, and the "assistance" was attempting to crack the admin password using a Windows SAM file Manning had provided.
- monocasa 8y agoThere's more to it than that, but IMO even that doesn't matter. So let's talk about this in 1970s terms. A whistleblower knows there are documents of import in a locked room. They take a picture of the locked door and give it the journalist. The journalist gives them instructions of how to pick the specific lock in a way that won't be traced back to them. The whistleblower then uses that information to break into the room and take the documents. Did the journalist commit a crime?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIf I understand correctly, yes - conspiracy to commit theft.
- monocasa 8y agoI mean, conspiracy to commit theft of documents to whistleblow is exactly the kind of thing that's protected by the first amendment's freedom of the press provision.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoYou are absolutely, completely wrong. That in no way is protected by the first amendment. The first amendment does not give the press the right to commit theft, of documents or of anything else.
- monocasa 8y ago'Conspiracy to commit theft' isn't 'theft'. Conspiracy is exactly the kind of charge that is protected or else you couldn't talk to a whistleblower until they had already acquired the documents. Just because you say 'you're wrong' doesn't make it true.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoAnd just because you say you're right, that doesn't make it true, either. No, conspiracy to commit theft isn't theft. It's still illegal, and it's not protected in any way. You're trying to use logic and the way you think the world works, or at least ought to work. You need to look at what the law actually says, and how it's actually applied.