3 ms·
That is an excellent question. It depends on how they selected the subject of the study [1] and how accurate is the evaluation at the beginning and the end of
by gus_massa 8y ago
That is an excellent question.
It depends on how they selected the subject of the study [1] and how accurate is the evaluation at the beginning and the end of the study [2].
That's why they need a control group, that is selected at random, so you hope that the cure rate in the control group is the same than in the main group if they didn't get the treatment.
Also, the groups must be double blind so when the doctors evaluate the results don't know if the patient has been treated or not, and they use the same criteria.
[1] Did they select only the mild case? Did they exclude the mild cases? Average age of the group? How much personalized help they can get to interact with other persons? Did other part of the study affect them? (Something like a minimal medical attention when they visit a nurse each month for minimal checks.) And a few more, that probably nobody know ...
[2] Some symptoms are crystal clear, and some are more fuzzy.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoRe double blind etc.. Not for pilot studies where one errs on the side of excluding null results in order to get the required funding to study something properly. Without pilot data, one judt wont get the grant that would play for the clinical trial