4 ms·
I can't help but eyeroll at that dumb trope of people unwilling to accept the genetic link as someone actually autistic but it brings to mind a socratically tro
by Nasrudith 8y ago
I can't help but eyeroll at that dumb trope of people unwilling to accept the genetic link as someone actually autistic but it brings to mind a socratically trolling joke.
"Doesn't this imply that being neurotypical is the actual disease and we have the means to deploy a cure for it?" Not a serious position but one to hopefully get people thinking about norms.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 8y agoWhat if one of the genetic links were related to the GI?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cannedslime 8y agoI think its because autism is something that gets thrown around everywhere these days. Im sure many are diagnozed with ADHD or similar condition on the autistic spectrum when in reality its probably more related to diet, upbringing etc. Autism can be genetic for sure. But I think many are diagnosed on the spectrum to hastely.
- ranit 8y agoIt is on the first sentence of the Abstract: autism-like behaviors >> Many studies have reported abnormal gut microbiota in individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD), suggesting a link between gut microbiome and autism-like behaviors.
- dragonwriter 8y agoAutism Spectrum Disorder is autism (it is the formal name of the DSM 5 diagnosis) not merely “autism-like behaviors”.
- ranit 8y agoThat sentence seems to suggest that the study includes (also) "autism-like behaviors". I am not trying to redefine Autism Spectrum Disorder as I don't have knowledge to do so.
- cannedslime 8y agoYes, but my point is that a general state of malnutrition can give the same symptoms as autism, ADHD etc. I think the lack of gut bacteria could be more a symptom than a cause if you know what I mean. When I was a child everybody thought I was autist when in reality I was just malnurished because I had a single mother who was up over her head in responsibility. If you dont eat right and maybe even live largely off sugar, you are bound to have attention span problems and blood sugar and mood like a roller coaster.
- ranit 8y agoMy comment was meant to agree with you and to point that the study seems to include patients that have "autism-like behaviors".
- b_tterc_p 8y agoJust because something is natural doesn’t mean it’s optimal, nor does just because something is optimal mean it’s what people want for themselves, nor does just because something needs to be tolerated means everyone should want to bear such things for themselves.
- gwbas1c 8y ago> the genetic link Don't jump to conclusions so quickly. Things that appear genetic could be related to family traditions that children follow when parents, environmental issues that are common along family lines, bacteria shared among parents and their children, ect.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt is more something highlighted by the psychology of popular "theories". There ino consistency in blaming autism on "refrigerator mothers", heavy metals, vaccines, and diet except for what they are not - environmental instead of genetic. It is reaching and in a frenzied, hysterical denial like Continuum Magazine ending after all involved died of AIDS complications. That sort of behavior suggests that they already know the answer is more likely than not genetic but they refuse to accept it because they don't like the implications. There are many things which should have broken said links but haven't - otherwise they would have played out already.