3 ms·
Considering the failure mode is fatal, it's not that unreasonable to expect people to turn off their phones in their cars in my opinion. If you are driving, yo
by ehnto 8y ago
Considering the failure mode is fatal, it's not that unreasonable to expect people to turn off their phones in their cars in my opinion.
If you are driving, you can't respond anyway, so just wait until you get to your destination to reconnect.
Phone use is now killing more people than drunk driving so I don't feel like it's an over-reaction. Drivers had their chance to be responsible and they killed a bunch of people instead.
- kurtisc 8y agoPhones have legitimate uses in cars. Satnav, music, or even just an indication that you just pull over and answer a phone. Given that I've never used one illegally, I think it's fair for me not to want to go through a power cycle for every journey. How could Uber work without one?
- ehnto 8y agoThe utility for devices in a car is obvious, no one is arguing that they aren't useful. But that's just a shame, because using them kills people every day and we haven't found a way to police it yet. Power cycling may just be a caveat of the policing methods. Driving is a privilege that is constantly abused. Perhaps we just couldn't handle unfettered use of devices in cars the same way we couldn't handle drinking and driving? I am all for some kind of controlled way of safe phone use in cars, but it doesn't exist. Better to remove the temptation until it does.
- mgamache 8y agoThat sentiment can be made about a lot of things including cars themselves: "The utility for cars are obvious, using them kills people every day. We just couldn't handle unfettered use of cars. I am all for some kind of controlled way of safe use of cars, but it doesn't exist. Better to remove the temptation until it does."
- ehnto 8y agoSure, but not about the downsides of removing them. It's a balance of pros and cons. Having people stop using their phones at all in a car wouldn't be a huge deal. It is only a recent problem after all. Not having the automobile would be devastating to the economy and people's lifestyles. The pros of phone use in a car are real, but shallow. The cons are that they cause accidents. It's heavily weighted toward cons.
- mgamache 8y ago"Phone use is now killing more people than drunk driving" do you have a reference for that statement?
- ehnto 8y agoIt was from a credible news source in (and about) Australia, but I can't find the news programmes data source. I did however find data to the contrary for America, https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/usdot-releases-2016-fatal-traffic-crash-data https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/usdot-releases-2016-fat... So I am probably wrong in regards to US fatalities. There were articles from insurance companies saying that distracted driving is more likely to cause an accident (fatal or non) than drink driving. I assume they were using their own data for that so I am not sure how credible it is: https://www.thezebra.com/texting-and-driving-statistics/ https://www.thezebra.com/texting-and-driving-statistics/