4 ms·
I think most people realize it thanks to the very good communication by SpaceX. Personally, from a technology standpoint, I am not that impressed compared to w
by GuB-42 8y ago
I think most people realize it thanks to the very good communication by SpaceX.
Personally, from a technology standpoint, I am not that impressed compared to what we have done in the past when it comes to space exploration. Moon landings, space shuttle, Mars rovers... The current state of rocketry all but highlights how awesome it was before.
The awesome part about SpaceX is not that their rockets are the best humanity can do. What's awesome is that it may very well make the first reusable rockets that make economical sense. Unlike NASA in the past, they don't have unlimited money, they are a private company, and even if they have help from the US government, they have to work with a budget.
If anything the achievement is not the rocket itself but how it creates a regain of interest in rocketry, both popular and economic. I mean, our workhorse rocket (Soyuz) dates back from the 50s, and all of the awesome (and too expensive) stuff like the Saturn V and shuttle are now lost.
- aswanson 8y agoI wonder what sparked interest in rocketry in the USSR enough that they launched Sputnik, etc with no immediate military benefit. As berated as communism is, they had vision enough to see past the capitalists in that moment...into space.
- greedo 8y agoI think you're underestimating the military benefit of being able to launch something into space...
- le-mark 8y agoIndeed, it was always a military application, v-1, v-2, launching sputnik was demonstrating the ability to put a warhead anywhere on earth. It was called the 'red scare' for a reason.
- BurningFrog 8y agoControlling the higher ground is always a military advantage.
- aswanson 8y agolol. you're right.
- simonh 8y agoAll the early Russian and US space launch systems were modified ICBMs. The US started their ICBM program immediately after WW2 the same as the Russians. It’s just that with the US developing the atomic bomb firsts, Russia had a stronger incentive to get a really big technological ‘First’ of their own. I’m not in any way denigrating the Russian achievement, but it’s not as though the US had no rockets of it’s own at the time and the military benefits were clear to both sides.
- stewfortier 8y ago> Personally, from a technology standpoint, I am not that impressed compared to what we have done in the past when it comes to space exploration. This is possibly the most Hacker News comment I have ever seen.
- maxkwallace 8y agoAll it needs is a McKayla Maroney "not impressed" meme and it'd be complete.
- tdhz77 8y agoRandom person with no creds here. I’m not impressed.
- vkou 8y agoIt's been 62 years since the first spaceflight. There are currently six people in space. 62 years after the first flight, world-wide air travel numbered a billion passenger-miles per day. So, pardon me, but the pessimism about space progress is fairly justified.
- fulafel 8y agoConsidering the havoc air travel is causing the environment, we should aim away from mass space travel for the foreseeable future.
- the_duke 8y agoMany people overestimate the environmental impact of air travel. It's "only" about 2% of global energy consumption. Not nothing, but also not that significant. There are much bigger energy wasters that can be targeted.
- fulafel 8y agoIt's the other way around unfortunately, people underestimate it: The effect of air travel on global warming is much higher, due to emissions effects in the upper atmosphere. Eg WP says 'Emissions weighting factor (EWFs) i.e., the factor by which aviation CO2 emissions should be multiplied to get the CO2-equivalent emissions for annual fleet average conditions is in the range 1.3–2.9' And air travel is growing at a steep rate because air travel has gotten so cheap and big populations in developing countries take up air travel.
- BurningFrog 8y ago> Unlike NASA in the past, they don't have unlimited money That money ran out, thus also proving limited.