2 ms·
How does Wikimedia determine which country’s laws it will comply with? Unless they have some physical presence in Germany, why wouldn’t they just tell the Germa
by philwelch 8y ago
How does Wikimedia determine which country’s laws it will comply with? Unless they have some physical presence in Germany, why wouldn’t they just tell the Germans to go pound sand instead?
- gruez 8y agoThe court's reasoning for why they have jurisdiction was outlined here: https://thewikicabal.com/2019/01/20/waibel-v-wikimedia/ https://thewikicabal.com/2019/01/20/waibel-v-wikimedia/ This is troubling because there's nothing preventing a Chinese court from claiming jurisdiction over the page on 1989 Tiananmen Square protests. Of course that request will be thrown out because, well... it's China, but with the direction EU's taking, it's only a matter of time before western European countries start sending more of these takedown requests.
- incompatible 8y agoI don't believe they comply with every edict from the likes of Turkey or China. Perhaps it's related to taking donations from Germany, or perhaps they want to be able to lobby its government and the EU without appearing to be a criminal organization.
- bscphil 8y ago> perhaps they want to be able to lobby its government and the EU without appearing to be a criminal organization. It's interesting because they would only appear that way to the EU itself. For ordinary people, especially in the United States (though I suspect elsewhere), Wikipedia is far more of a respected organization than the European Union. (To be clear, I mean that if Wikipedia says "what we're doing is okay" and the EU says "what you're doing is illegal", I think more people are going to believe Wikipedia. That's an interesting position to be in, whether it's ultimately useful to you or not.)
- incompatible 8y agoI think all governments would like to be able to enforce their laws on the Internet. The EU just has a bit more success than most due to the collective size and wealth of its member states. I don't know how to judge what ordinary people want. They seem generally happy to elect politicians who restrict free speech.
- voxic11 8y agoMaybe because Wikipedia is a community effort and it would be a loss if Germans could no longer contribute to it without aiding a criminal enterprise. At the very least German administrators would no longer be allowed, because they could be compelled by German courts to remove the entries.