6 ms·
It's not an arsenic-based life form
- seanalltogether 16y agoSo I'm curious if these cells can survive if reintroduced back in to the wild? "Next, what they did was culture the bacteria in the lab, and artificially jacked up the arsenic concentration, replacing all the phosphate (PO43-) with arsenate (AsO43-). The cells weren't happy, growing at a much slower rate on arsenate than phosphate, but they still lived and they still grew. These are tough critters." That seems to indicate that they wouldn't be able to compete with their cousins outside of a controlled environment.
- eru 16y agoSo even if there weren't arsenate based to begin with, now we do have artificial arsenate life forms?
- tokenadult 16y agoThis group of descendant cells, having been selected by natural selection for the laboratory environment with high arsenic concentrations, might indeed fare poorly if put into Mono Lake with its different environment. Perhaps their descendants would be so few as to be undetectable.
- kwantam 16y ago> That seems to indicate that they wouldn't be able to compete with > their cousins outside of a controlled environment. Not clear. They only grew more slowly when in a less friendly environment than they're used to. It's conceivable that the new environment selected for bacteria who can process AsO4 more quickly than the control strain, but it's not clear how well suited these new bacteria are to the original concentrations of AsO4 and PO4. Perhaps they'd do better, perhaps worse.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoI don't think most bacteria can even live outside of their "controlled environment". Like those in your gut or skin etc. So not sure what that means.
- amichail 16y agoAnyone think that the self-promotion done by Felisa Wolfe-Simon is a little strange? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJQkOs9_GE0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJQkOs9_GE0 http://www.ironlisa.com/ http://www.ironlisa.com/
- shaddi 16y agoIt was a little off-putting to me when I was watching the press conference, but it's pretty understandable given where she is in her career. If you look at her CV, she just finished her post-doc work last year. This is most likely her first year on the job driving her own research agenda and getting your work published in Science and widely discussed in the mainstream press can only help your tenure prospects.
- amichail 16y agoIs she looking for another job?
- shaddi 16y agoNo clue, I don't know her personally. But speculating from what she writes about on her website regarding her interest in teaching, I would assume she is interested in a faculty position at some point in the future. I really can't blame her for the self-promotion. I think this in some ways is the academic equivalent of the acquisition: she got the scoop on a really novel idea, she's well positioned to do future work in the area and be recognized as the global expert (catch the "more to come in the next 15-30 years!" in the press conference), and she's really excited about the work. I can only assume biogeochemistry is not having loads of money thrown at it these days so she's smart to take advantage of this opportunity to really make a name for herself.
- dawgr 16y agoDefinitely, terribly egocentric. I felt awkward as I was watching it, I thought scientists were the ones who were supposed to emphasize "us" v.s. "me". She did mention she worked with a team, but the "I"'s were more abundant than the "We"'s. I also caught a "myself and my team" instead of "my team and myself". She also talked a bit too much about herself. I understand that she was the leading scientist and the one who had the idea, but still, I don't think you are supposed to act like that as a scientist, it makes you look bad. Besides, she also seemed to kind of take it personal that the chemist wasn't entirely convinced yet. Oh and she also looked a bit frustrated when the journalist asked over the phone line a question that made it look as though it was discovered by chance.
- wccrawford 16y agoWhere in that article does it say that it's not an arsenic-based life form? In fact, it says exactly the opposite. It goes into detail about why it shouldn't be the much of a surprise. (Not that I agree with him.)
- astine 16y agoIn the title.
- ceejayoz 16y ago> Where in that article does it say that it's not an arsenic-based life form? Life on Earth is carbon-based. There are no phosphorous-based lifeforms that we're aware of, so replacing phosphorous with arsenic doesn't make a carbon-based bacterial species into an arsenic-based one.
- hartror 16y agoThis whole thing is yet another symptom of the science reporting ecosystem. Continual attempts at big bang news stories by institutions and their PR companies as well as a science media that goes for attention grabbing headlines. Is this interesting and significant news? Absolutely, but the way it has been reported devalues the actual science done and misrepresents the science (and science as a whole) to the wider public. Science is rarely about big bang eureka moments, it is long hard years in a lab building on someone else's work with a team of brilliant coworkers.
- alsocasey 16y agoTo be completely fair, the link downplays the news more than it really deserves imo. That a bacterium (even an extremophile) can even be coaxed into substituting arsenic for phosphorus in some of its basic biochemical processes is quite mind-boggling. I mean, how, by what mechanism is this achieved? The paper would have been stronger with some attempt at elucidating such a mechanism, but I can understand wanting to rush something like that out (particularly when it will certainly garner interest from a big name journal) before getting scooped.
- hartror 16y agoI think PZ provided a decent grain of salt, pointing out what about the research is important, what needs more work and most importantly what it isn't telling us.
- bbgm 16y agoIddo Friedberg has a great analysis of the paper: http://bytesizebio.net/index.php/2010/12/02/a-new-life-form-not-so-fast/ http://bytesizebio.net/index.php/2010/12/02/a-new-life-form-...
- NathanKP 16y agoThe way it has been reported devalues the actual science done and misrepresents the science (and science as a whole) to the wider public. I agree. One very unfortunate thing is that this article probably won't reach all the people who saw the first wave of articles and are now thinking that an alternate form of arsenic based life evolved and is still alive today. These people are the ones that receive the news via some chain email, and don't bother to research the rest of the facts or any of the follow up from the rest of the scientific community. This is the problem of treating science like a tabloid. Recently there has been a rash of speculation and downright silly articles based on misunderstood scientific discoveries. While on the one hand they often cause the public to take a greater interest in different scientific subjects, in many cases they are blown out of proportion or misrepresented.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yosho 16y agoThis is the best article I've read on the subject so far, short of the actual scientific publication. I like how the author dives deep enough to give a you a good understanding of what actually took place while not making it sound like a scientific journal.
- hartror 16y agoPZ is a reliable place to get the truth on biology/medicine based stories. For space stuff Bad Astronomy usually provides the lowdown on the latest space story flooding the main stream press. (http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/)
- sudont 16y ago> Although maybe being in California gives them extra weirdness points Good communication is always part showmanship, the author clearly grasps using a tone while remaining clear and concise. And while we’re at it, I don’t remember any article here that said it was arsenic-based life, just arsenic-using.
- athom 16y agoFavorite line: biochemistry is all about CHNOPS. Pronounce the "CH" like "SH".