9 ms·
Yes, but look at what you are saying. I fully agree that bacteria, rotifers, and other creatures can pick up genes. This is incredible. In fact, they've just f
by EGreg 16y ago
Yes, but look at what you are saying.
I fully agree that bacteria, rotifers, and other creatures can pick up genes. This is incredible. In fact, they've just found bacteria that substitute entire elements, which is incredible too.
What I am asking about, is the specific hypothesis:
"all speciation occurred via repeated application of mutation and natural selection, and no other factors were involved"
Now, I realize this would be impossible to test for ALL species, but wouldn't it be nice to have an example of at least ONE species that arose in this way through sexual reproduction? We have been breeding dogs for hundreds and thousands of years, and all of them are the same species! We have been adapting plants and never been able to create new species. Why is it so hard to do it, or it's just that we haven't tried hard enough?
I'm basically taking a skeptical approach here to the hypothesis, you see what I mean? It would be nice to just call it all "evolution" and assume the results. But I'd like some proof, some falsifiable predictions that have been tested.
- dnautics 16y agowell you better be willing to wait. Coli double every thirty minutes. The LTEE experiment took ten years. Find an organism that can sexually reproduce every thirty hours, and your equivalent experiment would take six hundred years.