3 ms·
>"Progressives" rail against stereotypes, but they're useful and we naturally form them for a reason - they help us survive. The problem is with people applying
by krapp 8y ago
>"Progressives" rail against stereotypes, but they're useful and we naturally form them for a reason - they help us survive. The problem is with people applying stereotypes formed in one environment to another environment where they're not applicable. Just keep that in mind when you're trying to be "woke."
Even if stereotypes acted as a survival mechanism in the past by providing a quick and dirty filter to judge threats through naive correlation and pattern matching, I don't believe they remain useful in the modern world. Modern stereotypes tend to be politically and culturally derived, rather than being the result of natural selection pressure, and so don't actually affect human survival so much as effect the survival of regressive human ideologies.
- veryworried 8y agoTaking a walk alone down a dark alley in a city at night where a rough looking person in a hoody is approaching you from the opposite direction with their hands in their pockets and happens to be a member of the race that is responsible for 90% of the homicides in that city may be enough to change your mind about stereotypes in the modern world...
- krapp 8y ago>Taking a walk alone down a dark alley in a city at night where a rough looking person in a hoody is approaching you from the opposite direction with their hands in their pockets and happens to be a member of the race that is responsible for 90% of the homicides in that city may be enough to change your mind about stereotypes in the modern world... Well. That's one of the more overtly bigoted comments I've seen here in a while. It wouldn't change my mind. The assumption one would assume you would expect to be drawn from "the race that is responsible for 90% of the homicides in that city" to "all else being equal, members of that race are likely to be homicidal," is not at all reasonable, or even mathematically justifiable. Anyone approaching you in a dark alley at night could be a threat, and still, on average, most likely isn't, regardless of race. If this is the best you can do to justify stereotyping as reasonable then I stand by my comment.
- veryworried 8y agoIf you act like everyone is an equal threat, you will go insane and become very antisocial, making it difficult to breed. If you act like no one is a threat, inevitably you will be killed, and will not breed. If you make a guess at who is or isn’t a possible threat (i.e. by stereotyping), you can reap the benefits of both stances. I don’t see anything bigoted about that. It is not the same thing.
- quxbar 8y agoYour body is trained to look for sugar. If you just eat what your body tells you to eat, you get diabetes really quickly. I think something has likewise disrupted the parts of your brain responsible for threat analysis.
- CuriouslyC 8y agoPart of the problem is that black culture in America has glorified being a "gangsta." As a result you have a lot of nice, decent individuals who comport themselves in a way that communicates negative things to people who aren't immersed in that culture enough to know better.
- veryworried 8y agoNor should they need to know better. Being a gangster should be a universally reprehensible thing, like being a drug dealer, or gang banger, or mafioso. Gangsters are killers and thieves.
- krapp 8y agoIt is bigoted. Given that scenario, "taking a walk alone down a dark alley in a city at night where a rough looking person in a hoody is approaching you from the opposite direction with their hands in their pockets" the race of the person should not, realistically, play a significant factor in determining the level of threat they present, as compared to the other factors. The bigoted assumption drawn from the made up statistic that the person is a member of "the race that is responsible for 90% of the homicides in that city" is that members of that race, categorically, are significantly more violent than members of other races. Otherwise, it and the statistic wouldn't be worth mentioning. However, if this were a reasonable assumption to make about members of a race, then the other factors should not be relevant. "Taking a walk down Main Street on a Sunday afternoon when a finely dressed gentleman who happens to be a member of the race that is responsible for 90% of the homicides in that city" would be a far more dangerous scenario to find oneself in than a "rough looking person in a hoody approaching you from the opposite direction with their hands in their pockets who happens to be your own race, in a darkly lit alley." Within the contrived scenario presented, the stereotype is irrelevant. Outside that scenario, it's absurd. And.. no one is talking about seeing everyone as an equal threat, or no one as a threat, that's a weird non-sequitur you're projecting onto my comment. Likewise, not being paranoid about certain races will not inevitably get you killed and prevent you from breeding. What I am claiming is that the stereotype you're trying to justify here as a valid survival mechanism is not.