4 ms·
I'm not going to get into the ideological debate of if the standards process is open enough or not but let me pose this: Is it not more likely the fact WPA2 was
by zamadatix 8y ago
I'm not going to get into the ideological debate of if the standards process is open enough or not but let me pose this: Is it not more likely the fact WPA2 was ratified in 2004 that it continues to be of questionable security to utilize in 2019?
- penagwin 8y agoI mean AES was established in 2001, and that's obviously still considered secure.
- zaroth 8y agoPrimitives vs Protocols. Encryption primitives rarely fail. The protocols build on top of them seem to consistently fail.
- benchaney 8y agoThere is no inherent reason that this is true, other than the fact that in order for primitives to be widely use they go through a open vetting process.
- hackdown 8y agoThe principle, the theory is always good. The protocols are implementations, and often implementations are badly done. See with all versions of SSL/TLS prior to TLS 1.3
- benchaney 8y agoNo, because: 1. WPA3, which has only recently been created, is riddled with issues. 2. Many things much older than WPA2 are still used today without major issues e.g. AES and RSA. The idea that standards processes aught to be open is not a ideological debate anymore. At this point it is a simple truth backed by overwhelming empirical evidence.
- zamadatix 8y agoThe process not being open != The process should have happened sooner In regards to 2 I disagree, see tls 1.0 as an example. Also aes isn't a protocol, apples to oranges.