5 ms·
Maybe I misread the article but I thought that the bacteria did not multiply if there was neither phosphorous nor arsenic present, but did multiply if there was
by colanderman 16y ago
Maybe I misread the article but I thought that the bacteria did not multiply if there was neither phosphorous nor arsenic present, but did multiply if there was arsenic but no phosphorous. I could be interpreting this wrong but this seems to rule out "neutralizing" or "getting rid of" the arsenic. (Otherwise why was it unable to multiply in the absence of phosphorous and arsenic?)
- crocowhile 16y agoBacteria multiply just fine (in fact better) with phosphorous but seem to cope with arsenic too. This is in my view a strong indicator of a mistake or flaw in the paper because it'd mean that if the authors' speculations were real, those bacteria would have evolved thus to modify a great deal of their biology just little enough to be able to incorporate both arsenate and phosphorus. It doesn't make sense. <a href="http://dl.dropbox.com/u/52420/Science-2010-Wolfe-Simon-science.1197258.pdf>Heres http://dl.dropbox.com/u/52420/Science-2010-Wolfe-Simon-scien... the PDF</a> of the paper, btw (I don't like scribd).