6 ms·
> Smolin concludes with the implications of all this for our understanding of space and time. He suggests that time is irreversible and fundamental, in the sens
by gus_massa 8y ago
> Smolin concludes with the implications of all this for our understanding of space and time. He suggests that time is irreversible and fundamental, in the sense that the processes by which future events are produced from present ones are truly basic: they do not need to be explained in terms of more basic ideas. Space, however, is different. He argues that it emerges from something deeper.
In Special Relativity space and time can be mixed (almost interchangeable), like the x, y and z usual coordinates.
If your coordinates and x and t, in a moving system the coordinates x' and t' are
x' = something1 * x + something2 * t
t' = something3 * x + something4 * t
The coordinates in the other system are just linar combinations of your coordinates. So how can be time and space have a different nature?
- inflatableDodo 8y agoYou can set up the imaginary plane and do transformations like that across it, but imaginary numbers and reals still have demonstrably different natures.
- goatlover 8y agoOne key difference is that time has a direction from past to future, while space doesn't.
- echelon 8y agoAt a cosmic level, space doesn't either. We're all affected by the big bang and can't go back. At small scales there are time-reversible (or symmetric) systems called time crystals. (I am not a physicist, so feel free to refute me.)
- gus_massa 8y agoThat is true, but it's not related to this problem. One important point is that you can't replace the "something" in the equation with whatever you like, for example something2 must be always smaller than something1 (if you add a few c here and there to have the correct units). If you select an event (i.e. a particular point of space, in a particular time) there is a cone of future events and a cone of past events and a region with the remainder events. The transformations don't change the future and past cones, but they mix space and time, so they must be mixable.
- jerf 8y agoYour equations are for Galilean space, in which your objection is correct; there is no way of distinguishing time from space, making the distinction arbitrary. This was not noticed for a long time. It was hard to tell until we had Einsteinian relativity to compare to. (Galilean space is actually broken in a lot of ways.) In relativity, those are not the correct equations; the correct equations observe the Minkowski [1] invariant -t^2 + x^2 + y^2 + z^2 staying invariant under all Lorentz transformations, and it's that negative sign before the t^2 that separates time in relativity. Time and space can be mixed in relativity, but they do still retain a distinctiveness; even when they get turned entirely "on their side" as inside a blackhole, time and space are still distinct, just very very twisted relative to the rest of the universe. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minkowski_space#Four-dimensional_Euclidean_spacetime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minkowski_space#Four-dimension...
- lisper 8y agoAnother interesting thing to note: because of the negative sign, Minkowski space obeys an inverse triangle law: a straight line is the longest route between two points (in terms of the relativistic interval) rather than the shortest. That is the reason for "time dilation". Clocks don't actually measure "time", they measure the relativistic interval, which just happens to be what we call "time" in our own reference frame. This insight makes it easier to understand the "twin paradox". If a clock takes any non-inertial trajectory between two events, its path through Minkowski space is shorter than it would be on an inertial (straight-line) trajectory, so the reading on the clock is lower than a clock that travelled on an inertial trajectory (straight line) between the same two events.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago> Your equations are for Galilean space At first I misread that as "Gallifreyan space", which almost makes sense.
- gus_massa 8y agoI' repeat the quote: > Smolin concludes with the implications of all this for our understanding of space and time. He suggests that time is irreversible and fundamental, in the sense that the processes by which future events are produced from present ones are truly basic: they do not need to be explained in terms of more basic ideas. Space, however, is different. He argues that it emerges from something deeper. Let's call the "truly basic" coordinate magic and the coordinates the "emerges from something deeper" nonmagic. In Galilean space you can't mix the special and temporal coordinates. The transformation, so they mix the special coordinates when there is a rotation, the time is the same time for everyone. ct' = ct x' = x + v/c ct So time can be totally different from space, because it doesn't get mixed by boost. You can proclaim that time is magic and the space coordinates are not magic. And there is no problem because the time is the same time for everyone. In the Minkowski space there is 1 time-like component and 3 space-like components, and they are different, because it is not an Euclidean space where the metric is defined by a positive-definite matrix (that is usually take as the identity to make the calculation simpler). In spite the 1 time-like component and 3 space-like components are somewhat different, they can't be very different because they get mixed with the boost, i.e. ct' = something(ct) + something (x) x' = something(ct) + something (x) I guess you know that the exact coefficients are in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_transformation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_transformation , but I'm too lazy to copy them. Let's suppose that in your reference frame (ct, x, y, z) time is magic and space is not magic (or the other way around). What happens in a reference frame that is moving at a different speed and the coordinates are (ct', x', y', z')? Is the new time ct' magic? But ct' is a linear combination of the original magic ct and the nonmagical x. In the original notation, is ct' something "truly basic" or it "emerges from something deeper" or it is a combination? How can it be "truly basic" if the result you get for ct' when you change your reference frame includes "somethin deeper"? Repeat the analysis for x', y' or z' depending on the direction of the boost.
- GoblinSlayer 8y agoI'm afraid, you infer too much from a mathematical formalism that is only good for calculations.
- gus_massa 8y agoNo. I infer this from the experimental results that say that[1] there is no preferred inertial reference frame, the speed of light is the same constant in all of them, and to change from a the coordinate system from a inercial reference frame to another inertial reference frame that is moving with a constant velocity you must use the Lorentz transformations that mix the spatial and temporal coordinates, and this transformation and other similar results in Special Relativity are verified experimentally [1]. [1] In a small scale and where gravity is small enough to ignore General Relativity. But General Relativity doesn't solve the mixing problem, it make it worst.
- crimsonalucard 8y agoThe thing with the time dimension is causation. Things that happened at t=0 influence t=1. The x, y, z dimensions have no such property. Stuff that happens on x=0 have no effect on x=1. Probability and entropy arise as a result of the causative nature of time, thus creating an arrow: "The arrow of time." There is no "The arrow of space." Probability in mathematics has certain axioms and the equations that arise from these axioms somehow apply very well to the real world. Like theories in physics probability is in itself a theory about the way the world works. It is also the axiomatic basis which we use to verify other theories. We assume probability is true. All other science arises as a result. Thus with probability being the axiomatic foundation of our sciences there is, as a result, no science behind itself. To use probability to verify theories of physics like gravity is one thing, but then what do we use it to verify the theory of probability itself? Nothing. We just assume it's true. That being said, I have not read the books described in the article but is understandable why at some point there is no rigor. It's because rigor at this point doesn't exist. When it comes to time, probability and entropy we are at the foundational assumption of all science. The only tools at this point are philosophical conjecture and random speculation. There is a difference with time and the other dimensions. We can see it with our eyes when we watch the world unfold and entropy rise... we literally have no clue why it's like this, this is one of the fundamental limits of our understanding.