3 ms·
> Btw, this debate is almost as old as human culture. It was already present in Aristotle (materalism) vs. Plato (idealism). Materialism vs. idealism is not th
by naasking 8y ago
> Btw, this debate is almost as old as human culture. It was already present in Aristotle (materalism) vs. Plato (idealism).
Materialism vs. idealism is not the same disagreement as realism vs. non-realism. Both materialism and idealism preserve counterfactual definiteness (CFD). The quantum interpretations that give up CFD are a fundamentally new paradigm, and a ridiculous one IMO.
For instance, the mathematical universe hypothesis is a new form of idealism, but it preserves CFD and so is realist.
- TelmoMenezes 8y agoThanks you for your reply. I will think more deeply about what you say, but unfortunately I have to work :) A quick reaction follows. > Materialism vs. idealism is not the same disagreement as realism vs. non-realism. True, but they are deeply related. Non-realism is only weird if you assume materialism. I'm not sure idealism is sufficiently well-defined that one can say that it preserves (or not) your definition of CFD. > The quantum interpretations that give up CFD are a fundamentally new paradigm, and a ridiculous one IMO. How do you interpret delayed-choice quantum eraser experiments? This is not a rhetorical question btw, I am 100% open to reading your take. > For instance, the mathematical universe hypothesis is a new form of idealism, but it preserves CFD and so is realist. Only with Tegmarks's later-added assumption that only objects describable by decidable computations are real.
- naasking 8y ago> How do you interpret delayed-choice quantum eraser experiments? A Bohmian interpretation will suffice to explain how realism tackles it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wheeler%27s_delayed-choice_experiment#Bohmian_interpretation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wheeler%27s_delayed-choice_exp...