4 ms·
"insert bunch of convoluted explanations" I disagree with that description. The explanation seems quite clear, and consistent with my understanding of the hist
by eesmith 8y ago
"insert bunch of convoluted explanations"
I disagree with that description. The explanation seems quite clear, and consistent with my understanding of the history.
"With the exception of Manifest Destiny, the U.S. had always been inward looking ... We ended up with far flung colonies because we kept stumbling into the role of major power. Prior to WWII, the only time we wrestled with the inevitability of our place was with the Monroe Doctrine"
Manifest Destiny is a huge exception - enough to make 'always been inward looking' be meaningless. It helped justify America's own imperialism. Quoting from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Paris_(1898) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Paris_(1898) , "The U.S. appealed to the principles of Manifest Destiny and expansionism to justify its participation in the war, proclaiming that it was America's fate and its duty to take charge in these overseas nations."
That Wikipedia article cites https://www.loc.gov/teachers/classroommaterials/primarysourcesets/spanish-american-war/pdf/teacher_guide.pdf https://www.loc.gov/teachers/classroommaterials/primarysourc... : "Victory in the Spanish-American War transformed the United States, a former colony, to an imperial power. Many Americans saw this development as a natural part of the nation’s “Manifest Destiny”--the belief that expansion of the United States was both right and inevitable."
We did not "stumble" into paying Spain $20 million for The Philippines. We need only look at the name 'American Anti-Imperialist League' to know that it was a considered decision.
Finally, "As for the pervasive racist beliefs, they had nothing to do with colonialism".
I find it hard to accept that statement without substantial evidence to show that works like:
"Race-Making and Colonial Violence in the U.S. Empire: The
Philippine-American War as Race War" - https://apjjf.org/-Paul_A_-Kramer/1745/article.pdf https://apjjf.org/-Paul_A_-Kramer/1745/article.pdf
"“Racism” and Colonialism: Meanings of Difference
and Ruling Practices in America’s Pacific Empire" - https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Julian_Go/publication/225264448_Racism_and_Colonialism_Meanings_of_Difference_and_Ruling_Practices_in_America%27s_Pacific_Empire/links/57481fa808aef66a78b1e116/Racism-and-Colonialism-Meanings-of-Difference-and-Ruling-Practices-in-Americas-Pacific-Empire.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Julian_Go/publication/2... . Quoting from it:
> It would seem indisputable that modern colonialism in the early twentieth
century involved racism. ... The historian Partha Chatterjee refers to this as “the rule of colonial difference”—the colonized, by virtue of their biology, were represented “as incorrigibly inferior” (1993, pp. 19, 33). Traditional scholarship has thus treated racism as “a built-in and natural product [of colonialism], essential to the social construction of an otherwise illegitimate and privileged access to property and power” (Stoler 1992, p. 322). More recent scholarship in the humanities has added that the very purpose of colonial discourse was “to construe the colonized as a population of degenerate types on the basis of racial origin; in order to justify conquest” (Bhabha 1994, p. 70). Almost by definition, then, modern colonialism entailed “racism”: ..
That last quote shows that your viewpoint that 'pervasive racist beliefs ... had nothing to do with colonialism' is far from being the majority held position among scholars.
Or as the article says, President William McKinley said that God told him to "educate the Filipinos, and uplift and civilize and Christianize them". How is that not racist?
As another counter-example, why did the US acquire Hawaii? It was not part of the continentalism "Manifest Destiny", nor was it part of the Americas under the Monroe Doctrine.
- barry-cotter 8y ago> As another counter-example, why did the US acquire Hawaii? It was not part of the continentalism "Manifest Destiny", nor was it part of the Americas under the Monroe Doctrine. Because there were tons of Yankee traders there and the local population was so decimated by disease that population replacement was possible, as in the continental US. This stands in marked contrast with the Philippines and Cuba. The Filipinos and Cubans were not going to drop like flies so they couldn’t be made a minority in their own land.
- eesmith 8y agoWhich is imperialism, yes? I want to see wahern explain the US acquisition of Hawaii and the Philippines in the framework of the US being "inward looking" non-imperial country bound by continental Manifest Destiny and the Monroe Doctrine.
- wahern 8y agoNo, it's not imperialism. I don't know if there's a word for it. Colonialism and imperialism imply much more cohesive political, economic, cultural, and military strategies. They're meaningful terms because they help to neatly describe both the shared motivations of powers (mostly European in recent history) and the shared experience of those who suffered under those powers. Using those labels in the context of American occupation of and atrocities in the Philippines and elsewhere doesn't add any clarity or explanatory power to American motivations or the experience of the victims. Some things are just things unto themselves, or require drawing much less convenient parallels--say, to modern China or ancient Persia. That's why I saw it's lazy and pernicious. Lazy because I think it's a framework that permits privileged American academics to criticize opponents (e.g. in the debate over the Iraq war, or in the debate over the legacy of slavery) without having to come to terms with their own culpability and inheritance; because colonialism and imperialism are so truly foreign to the American experience that one can easily see other Americans (now or historically) as imperialist but not one oneself. Fabricated narratives are more malleable that way. Pernicious because it only adds obfuscation and confusion, which is anathema to the truth and to the task of preventing future harms.