7 ms·
How to Hide an Empire: A History of the Greater United States
- erkose 8y agoI heard something related to this recently. The development of synthetic rubber meant we did not need to control regions with rubber plantation. This was mentioned in association with World War II. Another interesting point discussed was that in order to send secure communication by wire you had to control the land the wire traversed to prevent disruption of the communication. The invention of wireless communication meant that you only had to control the terminals of the communication.
- burlesona 8y agoIf only we had cost-effective synthetic petroleum :/
- erkose 8y agoOptimism: https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-47638586 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-47638586
- nitwit005 8y agoIt's not exactly like they had to control regions with rubber to have access to it. They could have just paid for it like we do today.
- bsamuels 8y agoUntil it gets seized by a rival country, at which point the only way you're getting it back is a declaration of war.
- nitwit005 8y agoAssuming there is a single source, and that rival country is completely determined to stop you from getting any of it, instead of selling it to make money as normal? More commonly they'd just put a tariff in place, which is likely cheaper to pay for than a war and occupation.
- erkose 8y agoI provided context for this, WW2. The Allies were cut off from the natural rubber supply of Southeast Asia at the beginning of the war. You can read more about it here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_rubber https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_rubber
- nitwit005 8y agoI understood the example, but speaking in generalizations at this point. I would note that the US struggled to produce rubber in the Phillipines, so they didn't exactly get that out of the occupation: https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/philippines/1926-07-01/rubber-and-philippines https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/philippines/1926-07-...
- BurningFrog 8y agoThis is also the dumb part of the theories about why the US invaded Iraq for the oil.
- wahern 8y ago> [T]he events that happened in the colonies are not remembered today because they were not deemed important at the time by the people who told memorable stories. ... > For Immerwahr, this transformation poses the puzzling question of why, at the height of its power, the U.S. decided to divest itself of all but a scattering of its territorial holdings. He argues [insert bunch of convoluted explanations] The answer is clear and was unwittingly already admitted: nobody cared. With the exception of Manifest Destiny, the U.S. had always been inward looking. We ended up with far flung colonies because we kept stumbling into the role of major power. Prior to WWII, the only time we wrestled with the inevitability of our place was with the Monroe Doctrine, which is less an exception and more an affirmation that the United States had little interest in imperial power for its own sake. Many political and industrial leaders wished otherwise and attempted to force the U.S. into the position, but it could never be sustained because of the domestic disinterest. It's no coincidence that the balance of political power shifted from the states to the Federal government at the same time the U.S. actively pursued a dominating international position--abortively prior to WWII but completely subsequent to WWII. And it's becoming increasingly clear that the end of the Cold War may have heralded a retreat to our old ways. Again, no coincidence that our national identity is as fractured as it ever has been in the modern era. A national identity that was defined in contradistinction to foreign identities, and an economy so dominated by foreign trade that economic interests in overseas, non-European markets could wag the dog--these are things the U.S. never experienced (at least not prior to WWII), but characteristics shared by every actual colonial and imperial power. As for the pervasive racist beliefs, they had nothing to do with colonialism. Conflating these things simply obscures the underlying dynamics. It's actually counterproductive because it permits people to deny the real racism by denying its imperialist past--which is easily denied because of facts. Similarly, it minimizes the continuously antagonistic, if not continuously genocidal, attitude toward Native Americans. By trying to shoehorn American history into the narrative of European and Japanese imperialism one is implicitly equivocating our treatment of Filipinos and Cubans the same way we treated the Native American nations. That's facially and tragically false. It's a lazy, pernicious attempt to import moral arguments from the anti-colonial movement into the American debate. It neither sheds light on historical tragedies (domestically or internationally) nor helps us grapple with our contemporary prejudices.
- 8y ago
- youeseh 8y agoRelated article for those interested: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2019/feb/15/the-us-hidden-empire-overseas-territories-united-states-guam-puerto-rico-american-samoa https://www.theguardian.com/news/2019/feb/15/the-us-hidden-e... "At first, “Pearl Harbor” was not the way most people referred to the bombings. “Japs bomb Manila, Hawaii” was the headline in one New Mexico paper; “Japanese Planes Bomb Honolulu, Island of Guam” in another in South Carolina. Sumner Welles, FDR’s undersecretary of state, described the event as “an attack upon Hawaii and upon the Philippines”. Eleanor Roosevelt used a similar formulation in her radio address on the night of 7 December, when she spoke of Japan “bombing our citizens in Hawaii and the Philippines”. That was how the first draft of FDR’s speech went, too: it presented the event as a “bombing in Hawaii and the Philippines”. Yet Roosevelt toyed with that draft all day, adding things in pencil, crossing other bits out. At some point he deleted the prominent references to the Philippines."
- billfruit 8y agoAlso in Commonwealth, it is remembered as the day when Japanese attacked Hong Kong. They took and occupied Honk Kong for the entire duration of the war.
- anbop 8y agoOne thing that obviates the need for colonies is international trade. You used to need to actually hold countries to make sure you had minerals, rubber, spices, etc. With the formalization of trade it's not as necessary.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jammygit 8y agoThere is a Hardcore History episode about Roosevelt that included a horrifying section on the Philippines. Its a fantastic episode but its unsettling too
- thomasmarriott 8y ago"I am persuaded no constitution was ever before so well calculated as ours for extensive empire and self government." Full context of "empire": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empire_of_Liberty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empire_of_Liberty
- spyckie2 8y agoThis is not a great article. First, if you mention that America has an overseas empire, you probably need to let us know exactly what the empire contains. Maps of European imperialism exist and help us understand what an "overseas empire" actually looks like. In the article, aside from the Philippines, there is no mention of any other largely populated countries. We have no idea of the scale of the "American Overseas Empire" at all. Second, if you're trying to say that the American Empire is larger than it's colonization, it's be nice to let us know, again with a map, the sphere of influence under American rule. Telling us that America has many military bases is a poor substitute. Finally, the author is picking through straw with his examples of Jefferson and FDR. America is an empire. It's influence has been global since the turn of last century. The extent of American influence is seen everywhere. There are many books and articles on America's influence on the world that fairly cover both sides of history. The reason why colonization is not often talked about is because it's an outdated and inefficient practice that America just didn't care much about. It's why the Europeans deprecated it - ruling a country in order to benefit from it's resources is inefficient because you actually have to govern it and govern it pretty well for you to have any long term benefits. There's much easier and more direct ways for you to gain benefits from others, and believe it or not, most of them are mutually beneficial to both parties.
- muzani 8y agoDeprecation is a good way of putting it. I've always said that modern colonialism is in tech. If a top telco or a power plant relies on Google, then they are effectively colonized by Google. If some human traffickers rely on PayPal and Salesforce, they delegate control and data to those companies. This is also the main appeal of crypto, block chain, and open source; decentralization gives back control. The US plays this game well, but again, it looks inside. Countries like China and Germany are doing best at extending their influence outside the country.
- hhs 8y agoOP here. Please note that this piece is a review of Daniel Immerwahr's book, "How to Hide an Empire: A History of the Greater United States".
- JohnClark1337 8y agoAmerica Bad
- bunnycorn 8y agoNon-American here. This is how I expect media to describe the US External Politics If President is Democrat: * If President Raises Military Expenditure: "he is helping protect the people of the world from tyrant governments" * If President Lowers Military Expenditure: "we cant afford this many wars, we must instead focus on our own problems, we must focus on (insert recent catastrophe, that's inevitable in the US like a wild fire in the West Coast or a tornado in the East Coast)" If President is Republican: * If President Raises Military Expenditure: "he is being imperialist, we don't want this blood in our hands" * If President Lowers Military Expenditure: "he is letting the tyrants like him do their bidding, remember the little kids in Africa, if we don't step in, who will?" Beautiful!
- billfruit 8y agoAs commentor mentioned at the original site, I think the article would have benefitted from discussion how Texas and Louisiana ended with the USA. Also of the territories taken from Mexico in the early to mid nineteenth century.
- teslaberry 8y agohttps://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-arts-and-culture/281731/chinas-plan-for-global-supremacy https://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-arts-and-culture/281731/chi... China is the 'hidden empire'. u.s. is pretty out in the open, and losing the growth and maintanance of its empire viz-a-viz china in almost EVERY part of the globe except brazil, phillipines and a few other crucial locations. they are winning in australia, japan, korea, ITALY, pakistan, and are making inroads to dominate africa and south america. funny the u.s. empire is not hidden for anyone looking for it. Why? because the internet makes it very easy to track a not so well disguised extension of empire through small military bases, but moreso through economic expansion of debt instruments and global petro dollars. But you must look at where empire is going. it used to be based on controlling oil. Data and communications tech are the new oil. AFter banking and finance, the newest most important industry for the next few centuries is telecom/data. google and facebook , amazon, microsoft and apple are all massively tied into the military system of information in the u.s. however china doens't have the handcuffs on . It doesn't have to pretend to its own citizens that they are NOT part of the matrix, and thus their citizens are more eager to accept that this digital teletech toolset used to control them, should be used in the most aggressive manner to control those outside their 'country' in order to benefit those inside it, or at least the leadership. In essence, the chinese trust their authoritarian government to be authoritarian, and this is a massive cultural advantage with respect to the aggressive expansion of empire. thus, the empire of telecommunications based economic-information is spreading globally and rapidly through the emerging markets especially where inexpensive high quality chinese phones and telecommunications infrastructure utterly dominates against western telecom providers. it's not just cost, but the ease with which chinese will work with other countries. there are not foolish sets of federal western style bribery laws and contract documentation to follow. they ahve already laid down their hidden empire. it will rise over the next hundred years and the tipping point will be recognizeable when western signal intelligence agencies have zero clue what is going on with their puppet dictators because the chinese will have scooped them.