2 ms·
That's some particularly hilarious timing giving boeing's recent "unsafe to fly our plans" headline news. As someone in Canada it's been disappointing to watch
by munk-a 8y ago
That's some particularly hilarious timing giving boeing's recent "unsafe to fly our plans" headline news.
As someone in Canada it's been disappointing to watch the massive internal subsidies given to Boeing (from the US government) help sink Bombardier - though the company also did under-perform.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoDoesn't every country do the same thing— albeit perhaps not at the same scale? When Embraer complained about Bombardier's subsidies from the Canadian government, the WTO decided that they were illegal. Then Bombardier complained about Embraer's subsidies from the Brazilian government and the WTO decided that those are illegal too.
- munk-a 8y agoYea, but the WTO hasn't gone after the blatant US protectionism - that's the issue. Most other countries are kept relatively in check in terms of trade fairness, but the US is riding their golden chariot.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoI'm assuming the justification for the EU tariffs was the WTO's decision last month that the state of Washington is giving Boeing an illegal subsidy in the form of tax breaks.
- matt4077 8y agoIt's probably somewhat rare in industrialised democracies these days. Many trade deals limit subsidies (hence this WTO ruling). It is also difficult to give one-off subsidies in diversified markets, because (domestic) competitors would complain/sue. The EU has especially stringent rules against this, making (for example) shenanigans such as Amazon's HQ2 race-to-the-bottom impossible. That's also what got Apple and Ireland into trouble. It's effectively a cartel of countries pooling power to counter multinationals' ability to offshore profits to the cheapest jurisdiction. The are exemptions: The EU and US massively support agriculture with direct payments. Canada does the same with milk quotas. (These two systems are somewhat incompatible: allowing subsidised US milk to be sold for Canada's protected high prices would amount to double dipping. Hence some disagreements across that particular border). Aircrafts are a rather special beast: there's a national security angle, they are objects of national pride, and both the EU and US have one large manufacturer. Airbus is also diversified across many EU countries, assuring them wide political support.
- village-idiot 8y agoSubsidy of “national champion” companies is pretty common but not universal. Sweden allowing Saab to fail without opening up the national purse comes to mind. Defense related industries are typically pretty pretty high on the subsidy list though, for all the obvious reasons.