3 ms·
While archaeologists definitely do tend to underestimate the viability of sea voyages, don't consider 1491 a work of fact. It's rather fast and loose with its i
by contingencies 8y ago
While archaeologists definitely do tend to underestimate the viability of sea voyages, don't consider 1491 a work of fact. It's rather fast and loose with its interpretation. Zheng He or members of some of his 7 voyages did get to the east coast of Africa, but any further movement is not supported by either evidence or literature.
You can check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-Columbian_trans-oceanic_contact_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-Columbian_trans-oceanic_co... for some debunking.
Most places on earth, America included, are or were reachable in small watercraft at certain times of the year, even without sail, given certain weather conditions. Only the remotest islands truly required advanced seafaring for repeat navigation.
Anyway, aside from isolated boating incidents there are far more impressive stories that are buried by popular history and its political supporters - the use of Persian as a lingua franca for trade and diplomacy as far away as China, various Indian Kingdoms throughout Southeast Asia and up to the Chinese border, entire civilizations whose expanse was extremely significant but virtually nobody has heard of, successful cultural genocides on grand scales, etc.
- nbonaparte 8y agoYou seem to have confused 1421 with 1491. The latter is generally considered to be a well-researched book while the former is, as you say, merely a grand tale.
- contingencies 8y agoPerhaps, Bonaparte! But look at you resurfacing for articles on bony parts!
- hinkley 8y agoIn order to have a stable population you need like 220 people, right? Or steady genetic trade with another civilization. So we’d be talking about more than a couple boat people making it to an island and having a ton of kids. In other words, I don’t think a fluke crossing establishes a civilization. It takes more order than that. Unless the reason these early populations have been replaced by Polynesians is because they weren’t diverse enough and faded out...