3 ms·
Did you see the movie Interstellar? He included it in his video. That's what the black hole looks like, except with the relativistic beaming make one side brigh
by manigandham 8y ago
Did you see the movie Interstellar? He included it in his video. That's what the black hole looks like, except with the relativistic beaming make one side brighter than the other.
Here's the image from the movie: https://www.wired.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/ut_interstellarOpener_f.png https://www.wired.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/ut_interste...
Now imagine that image being taken far away by several ground-based telescopes put together at the edge of their capabilities and using math to error correct and stitch together the final result. What you get is what we saw.
- wallace_f 8y agoAh, sure. Also, if you go to the EHT's own website, they have a gallery of predicted, simulated images. Here is another prediction: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/04/here-s-what-scientists-think-black-hole-looks https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/04/here-s-what-scientis... I just wanted to know why he went with that one because his prediction was really accurate. And I thought him saying 'just trust me' was bad form. He did talk some about this, but he didn't really say anything about why he thought his illustration would be so accurate compared to a lot of other stuff seen in the press. I dont care (or have any idea why) how many downvotes or insults I get. It is a perfectly reasonable question and criticism.
- manigandham 8y agoI don't see the difference, the predictions are the same. The only changes in the image depend on what angle the black hole is being viewed at which would influence whether we see a band across the middle and the slimmer inner ring.
- wallace_f 8y agoLol the image I linked is obviously very different. There is some groupthink going on here affecting people like you and others. The above is obviously plain.
- manigandham 8y agoThere are 4 images on that page, 1 of which is the Interstellar movie rendition that I already linked to. They are also all the same model only in better detail as graphics technology has improved. Perhaps you should post exactly what image you're talking about and what you think is different.
- wallace_f 8y agoIn the images I linked to, the black hole images don't have any "blobbiness," and seem to have these perfect gradiants. In the veritasium video the "coffee stain" was not really as blobby as the real image, but it seemed a lot closer than the smooth-gradiant, no blobbiness and no irregularities predictions. I dont just mean the fuzziness from low resolution. This isn't really a big deal, but it's also obvious that I am just stating plain facts about what is in these images. At the time I saw this video when he said "you can be confident, because... (no reason given)" was really the thing that I thought was annoying. I think you can see the differences in the images. They're not huge but the smooth gradiants vs irregularities/coffee stain/blobbiness is plain to see I think. Edit: from the horses mouth himself, one of the lead researchers says he didn't expect the image to look like it did: https://youtu.be/ZrDhHDBHkQY https://youtu.be/ZrDhHDBHkQY Some of the people here in other parts of this thread have been really offensive for this. It's honestly pretty ridiculous.
- manigandham 8y agoThe general model of what a black hole looks like is well understood. The highest definition rendering is that in Interstellar, except for one side being brighter than the other due to the relativistic beaming. They kept that part out of the movie to just make it look nicer. All the models are the same, and the real picture is "blobby" only because of the process in how it was taken. I think you are refusing to accept that but there's nothing else to say about it. It wasn't a direct photo, it was a complex assembly of several different radio telescopes around the world stitching data together. If we were actually next to it, it would very much look like the one from interstellar. The video you linked isn't about the prediction being wrong, more that he just didn't expect to really see a black hole at all. Even though black holes are generally understood for decades, there's a certain shock and awe to seeing it real for the first time.