2 ms·
The article summarized: Basically, for any given event, there may be two or more "whys" which feed into it, which in turn may have have two or more "whys" which
by peter_d_sherman 8y ago
The article summarized: Basically, for any given event, there may be two or more "whys" which feed into it, which in turn may have have two or more "whys" which feed into it.
We see this pattern in databases, where there are 1..n relationships out of something, or, in reverse, n..1 relationships into something.
The "5 Whys" described whys only as having a single cause feeding into each successive cause. This article describes the problem with that, which is simply that in the real world, a single result, a single "why", might have multiple (1..n) causes feeding into it, and multiples into those.
Now... get ready to have your mind blown... Here's the "problem" with this article (I know, this article makes more sense than the "five whys" alone, but hear me out!)
Think of "The Five Whys" as level 1 reasoning and this article as level 2.
Level 2 is smarter because it considers more.
So what's level 3?
Level 3 then, which I think will be discovered (or at least expounded upon by some person vastly brighter than myself), is using the level 2 method, and expanding that set of predecessor causes even more to everything in life, which theoretically should result in the observation that everything is circular.
That is, all events, causes and circumstances -- eventually feed back on themselves! Some to lesser degrees, some to greater degrees, but I think it will be discovered that all causes move in circular loops, even though the cause->effect->cause chain (or chains) might have thousands, perhaps hundreds of millions of elements...
I think the ancient Greeks (well, some of them, the enlightened ones anyway) had an understanding of this. I think that Shakespeare and Dante Alighieri understood this, at least in terms of the human character.
Consider Toyota... If Toyota is asking "why" some failure occurred and tracing it back 5 levels, then one might ask "Why does Toyota have to make cars in the first place?", because that sets the stage for all other "whys" that come next...
Eventually, with enough "whys", everything has to be circular... You just need to go enough why levels "deep" to see this. And some causes feed other causes to lesser degrees, some to greater degrees.
And I believe that people in antiquity who were men of great learning... somehow knew or intuited this... while not provable, it seems "logical"...
Loops inside of loops inside of loops... all with different loop lengths...