2 ms·
>You can't end a 5 Whys with 'another team I depend on screwed up'. You have to own your software or service. If you depend on something, you need checks, alarm
by BeetleB 8y ago
>You can't end a 5 Whys with 'another team I depend on screwed up'. You have to own your software or service. If you depend on something, you need checks, alarms, and whenever possible the ability to handle dependency failure well.
On the big picture, I agree with GP - different people will come to very different conclusions with the "Why" game - because the world is complex, and many factors come into play when something goes wrong. You don't need to fix all of them, but it does become a game of figuring out the most convenient aspect to fix (and no, another level of "Why" won't fix that).
Somewhat related: I had a 2nd level manager who in meetings kept saying "In an ideal world, ..." and using that as a starting point for requirements, problem solving, etc. At one point, I interrupted him and said "Nope. In an ideal world, I would not need to work for a living. Your ideal is already far from it, so let's not make distinctions between ideal and non-ideal."[1]
It's easy to use the "whys" to come up with answers like "Because X needs to make a living" and "Because the incentives with the manager/department/org/company create a situation where testing is devalued (despite all claims by management to the contrary)" or "Because we cannot retain talent due to our compensation policies" or "Because people in the team are unwilling to learn version control systems newer than cvs."
These are not facetious answers - they should be treated on an equal footing with technical solutions. In my experience, management that does not want to deal with solutions that involve other teams/people/policies are ones where the work has been miserable. It's also been my experience that SW people seem to prefer technical solutions over alternatives, which is tragic. When you study things like negotiation, it's almost inverted. They have their own push for "Why", but the push is usually in the motives direction. The person you're dealing with is presenting a concrete demand that may seem objective, but behind it is almost always a fairly human reason (not looking bad, higher status, etc). And they always emphasize trying to root cause to those and addressing them.
Many here know the saying: In the top tech companies, all problems are social ones. They have the talent to achieve anything. If any piece of SW fails, it's not because they didn't have technically capable people. It's because they failed in the social/organizational domain. So when I hear management say they don't want to address that in the 5 Why's, I see management that is solving the wrong problem.
I took a systems engineering class once. The thing they emphasized throughout is "If every aspect of a product is designed perfectly as its own unit, you'll get a crappy product that will not win in the marketplace." The idea is that a perfect widget in isolation may not integrate well, and there are budgetary issues as well. There has to be a certain amount of compromise to integrate with other widgets in the product, and the teams involved need to talk to one another and have dependencies on one another. The role of the system engineer is to oversee that this is happening.
Insisting that your SW or service must be bulletproof of other services, when both are related and in the same product, is highly suboptimal (as is the other extreme). Often the optimal solution is to say "Our service will work, provided service Y works".
[1] I was on good terms with him so I got away with it.