6 ms·
I don't know how I feel about making a device so endlessly hackable a "security key".
by Hamuko 8y ago
I don't know how I feel about making a device so endlessly hackable a "security key".
- lostmsu 8y agoAren't you already using Authenticator running on an Android device?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoThat doesn't mean I think it's a good idea. A phone is better than nothing. A real token would be much better.
- ghaff 8y agoI'd argue using Authenticator is better than simply not using 2FA. Which is probably the choice for a lot of people for whom always carrying some dedicated hardware device is not really a realistic option.
- vcavallo 8y agoabsolutely. it’s a second thing to hack. just because it’s _possible_ to hack the second thing doesn’t mean it isn’t helpful.
- jetrink 8y agoIn what way is carrying a dedicated device not realistic? My second factor lives on my keyring and is only a bit larger than a typical door key. Everyone carries keys.
- ghaff 8y agoI don't carry my keys when I'm traveling if I'm not driving my own car. So, no, not everyone carries keys. ADDED: I do have other 2FA hardware as well. But I assume I'm not guaranteed to have it with me when I need it.
- scarejunba 8y agoAh, you have separate keyrings for your home keys and car keys? I'd say that's not usually the case.
- ghaff 8y agoNo. I have a keypad on my door. So when I take a trip by air (which is common), I just leave my keys at home. But I agree that my scenario may not be super common.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- danans 8y agoIt's common in any situation where you share a car with other people.
- int_19h 8y agoWhich, in turn, is more common outside of US.
- Kalium 8y ago> In what way is carrying a dedicated device not realistic? For most people, it's so far outside what they're familiar with that it feels alien and incomprehensible. It makes absolutely no sense to them. So they're not going to do it or adopt it quickly. User education will catch up in time, but that will take quite a long time.
- Hamuko 8y ago>For most people, it's so far outside what they're familiar with that it feels alien and incomprehensible. It makes absolutely no sense to them. The Google Titan Key looks like a car keyfob, so I don't really agree with you on this.
- Spooky23 8y agoIt doesn’t add value for most applications for service providers. TOTP for GMail assures Google that the same person who enrolled the account was given custody of a key. The physical token only adds value in scenarios where phones aren’t available or you need to assure the identity of the individual.
- Johnny555 8y agoI don't normally drive a car (I take transit to work) so I don't carry car keys. I have an electronic lock on my door at home, so I don't carry house keys. I don't carry keys of any type. My phone case has a slot for credit cards, so all I normally carry with me is my phone, a credit card, my work badge, and my transit pass.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- oarsinsync 8y agoGoogle Authenticator is just Google's front end to an open standard (TOTP). Authy, 1Password, various CLI apps, they all implement this same standard. Lots of independent websites market this form of 2FA as "Google Authenticator". It's kinda like asking people to enter their gmail address (rather than their email address). Eitherway, TOTP is a big step away from putting all your 2FA eggs in Google's basket.
- Animats 8y agoUm, yes. Plus it uses "Google Cloud". A security key device ought not to be remotely writeable.
- guelo 8y agoAll Android devices certified by Google will have a hardware security module which should keep the keys secure. Some cheap non-certified devices (mostly Chinese) might not have hardware backed keystores, but I doubt those devices would be able to run this Google app.
- JohnFen 8y agoIf a Google app is required for this, we've already entered the "can't be trusted" category.
- penagwin 8y agoNot doubting you, but were did you find that information? The only thing I see is "it’s built into devices running Android 7.0+" and I found that on multiple pages. As Android 7.0 is available to install on any device and I don't see anything about "certified android devices", I assume they mean ANY Android 7.0 device? Then again it only works with Google services atm, but I know you can sideload google play services so... https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/6103523 https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/6103523
- lern_too_spel 8y agoAndroid 7 supports key attestation. https://source.android.com/security/keystore/attestation https://source.android.com/security/keystore/attestation
- munchbunny 8y agoThat's great, but that doesn't actually guarantee that this new feature requires that the phone is using the hardware security module, just that you'd be able to prove if it it was. Don't get me wrong, it's still better than TOTP in many ways, but having the actual security coprocessor is a big distinction.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThere is no practical difference. For people who need the security, this API can guarantee it.