5 ms·
Let's say that 127 million people don't like the Mona Lisa. What does that tell you about the quality of the painting? Nothing. That's why downmodding is a bad
by Alex3917 19y ago
Let's say that 127 million people don't like the Mona Lisa. What does that tell you about the quality of the painting? Nothing. That's why downmodding is a bad idea.
- cstejerean 19y agoThat's why I didn't vote for that option myself. People keep asking about it though. One option would be to let users flag content as not appropriate for HN, and then have a per user option of filtering away content the community doesn't find appropriate.
- spydez 19y agoI'm all for flagging the content. It'd be especially nice if it'd throw up a warning in front of the summary if enough people flag it. Digg does pretty well in this regard. If enough people bury the story as inaccurate, you see a big "Warning! The contents of this article may be inaccurate!". That plus scanning a few comments are helpful for deciding not to waste my time on an article. Suggested flags include: 'inaccurate', 'nsfw', 'not suitable for HN', etc.
- ComputerGuru 19y agoAgreed.
- axod 19y agoDemocracy sucks :/
- jraines 19y agoRight. Also, people are much more inclined to try mold the front page into their idea of what the site should be using down arrows than they would any given comment page.
- comatose_kid 19y agoLet's say that 127 million people like the Mona Lisa. What does that tell you about the quality of the painting?
- xlnt 19y agoi declare you the winner.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- dusklight 19y agoLet's say that 127 million people LIKE the Mono Lisa. What does that tell you about the quality of the painting? For your argument to be sound, it has to apply equally to upmodding as to downmodding. So might as well get rid of modding entirely and just have all the crap come in unfiltered? It is true that if a lot of people downmod something, this does not necessarily mean that thing sucks. But it is also true that A LOT OF THE TIME when a lot of people downmods something, that thing does in fact suck. Hows about we add downmodding and also tags and a way for each user to specify his/her own set of filter parameters?
- run4yourlives 19y agoUsing that logic though, why have it on comments but not on posts?