5 ms·
If complicated taxes are a Republican anti-tax strategy, why did Reagan and the 1980s republicans pursue a strategy of vastly simplifying the tax code? Doing t
by gowld 8y ago
If complicated taxes are a Republican anti-tax strategy, why did Reagan and the 1980s republicans pursue a strategy of vastly simplifying the tax code?
Doing taxes is a tax -- in hours and fees. Only the wealthiest people who can spend $10K on tax prep to save $100K via loophole deductions, oh.
- jacobolus 8y agoSimplifying the tax code in the 80s was the public sales pitch. The real strategy was to dramatically cut taxes on the wealthy (e.g. by eliminating the top several marginal tax brackets). But keep in mind, the Democrats controlled congress, so reform had to gain bipartisan support.
- twoodfin 8y agoThis chart doesn’t show evidence of a particularly dramatic cut in effective rates for the top 1% of earners: https://taxfoundation.org/taxes-rich-1950-not-high/ https://taxfoundation.org/taxes-rich-1950-not-high/
- jacobolus 8y agoThe top 1% of earners today earn a dramatically larger share of total income than the top 1% in the 1950s. If taxes kept up, they would have noticeably higher effective tax rates than they used to have. P.S. The “Tax Foundation” is a right-wing “think tank” (i.e. activists masquerading as researchers) funded by billionaires and corporations. I would however recommend reading the whole paper they cite, http://gabriel-zucman.eu/files/PSZ2017.pdf http://gabriel-zucman.eu/files/PSZ2017.pdf > Government redistribution made growth more equitable, but only slightly so. After taxes and transfers, income in the bottom quintile stagnated (+4%) over the 1980–2014 period while it grew a meager 21% for the bottom 50% as a whole. That is, transfers erased about a third of the gap between macroeconomic growth (61%) and growth for the bottom half of the distribution (+1% before government intervention). Taxes did not hamper the upsurge of income at the top, which grew almost as much as pre-tax. > The top panel of Figure II provides a granular view of who benefitted (or not) from growth, by showing the annualized real growth of pre-tax and post-tax income for each percentile of the distribution over the 1980–2014 period, with a zoom within the top 1%. There are two striking results. First, the vast majority of the population—from the bottom up to the 87th percentile—experienced less growth than the (modest) macro rate of 1.4% a year. For instance, the 10th percentile declined by 0.6% a year pre-tax (+0.3% post-tax); the 30th percentile stagnated pre-tax and grew 0.6% post-tax; the 80th percentile grew 1.2% pre-tax (+1.3% post-tax). Only the top 12 percentiles of the population achieved a growth rate as high or higher than the macro rate of 1.4%. Second, even percentiles 88 to 98 experienced unimpressive income gains, between 1.4% and 2.2% a year—in most cases less than the macro growth rate of U.S. incomes for the preceding generation, from 1946 to 1980. The only group that grew fast is the top 1%, whose average income increased 3.3% pre-tax and 3.2% post-tax, with growth culminating at +6.0% a year for the top 0.001%. The top 1% has pulled apart from the rest of the economy—not the top 20%. etc.
- hnmullany 8y agoNo-one paid the top brackets because the tax code at that point was riddled with ways to generate tax losses that reduced liability. The tax reform really was a good thing (unlike 90% of what happened under the Reagan administration) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_Reform_Act_of_1986#Passive_losses_and_tax_shelters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_Reform_Act_of_1986#Passive...
- llukas 8y agoThere is openly available IRS data on how many households actually paid highest bracket. You are wrong that nobody paid it.
- Eyes 8y agoForget Reagan, they claimed they were trying to do it last year. Remember the post card?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoBy cutting the ability to deduct SALT they made tens of millions of people who would have otherwise itemized do a simple 1040. While not a postcard it did greatly simplify taxes for many people. That said, most of those people are still going to see it as a travesty because they had to pay a little more (god forbid people rich enough to have thousands of dollars of SALT pay taxes on the income used to pay that SALT).
- BurningFrog 8y ago> If complicated taxes are a Republican anti-tax strategy... Republicans only last year substantially simplified tax filing.
- thisone 8y agoabout the only simplification on mine was that I no longer have to file that I have a full year exemption on the health care law. However I do have to file an extra sheet of paper now just to fill out a single line for foreign address that's been removed from the 1040.
- throw0101a 8y agoAre you talking about the postcard publicity stunt? * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LhKoefZ2QI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LhKoefZ2QI
- Dig1t 8y agoThe idea is not to make the taxes deliberately complex, it is more about the notion of who is telling whom what is owed. A system where the citizen says "hey government, I think I owe you this much in tax because x" is fundamentally different than a system where the government says "hey citizen, you owe me this much in taxes, here's your bill". In the second situation, the average (complacent) citizen will not look twice at the bill, but rather just pay it and get on with their life. In the former situation, the citizen is forced to have a 3rd party create a statement that says "I owe you this much because x" and because of natural incentives, the company will try to claim the maximum number of [incentives, loopholes, deductions, whatever you want to call them] so that the client saves the most amount of money. Of course the company takes its cut and I'm not arguing that greedy companies are the perfect solution. I'm just saying that there is more to the argument than simply it being a matter of lobbyists getting their way.