4 ms·
It's also limited to straight text. People may say it's frivolous, but sending pictures and other media is expected now.
by jandrese 8y ago
It's also limited to straight text. People may say it's frivolous, but sending pictures and other media is expected now.
- Washuu 8y agoIRC is not limited to plain text. Discord, Slack, and IRC all handle media the same way. Someone sends an URL and the client decides to how to handle displaying it. Textual shows me images and videos all the time from URLs sent.
- civilian 8y agoI guess then technically IRC servers need a way to have images uploaded and re-serve them. When I share an image on slack I'm usually just uploading it directly to slack, rather than using imgur or another uploader.
- jandrese 8y agoI thought they stored the graphics on the server with Discord. I know there is that out-of-band file protocol that some IRC clients support, but it was always a terrible hack that hated firewalls.
- jjeaff 8y agoThat's not how I use the feature at all. The vast majority of images and files I send are created locally. I can then upload or paste then into the chat client, they get stored on the server and shown to the other users. With IRC, I would need to use a separate service like imgur to first upload the images. And or a file hosting service like Dropbox for the files.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoA robust IRC client could include integrated image hosting. Or ask you to plug in your Dropbox account, and then upload there automatically when you drag and drop a file or image.
- StreamBright 8y agoHave you seen irccloud?
- okasaki 8y agoThat's incorrect - you can send binaries over IRC with DCC.
- misnome 8y agoUnless things have changed since my IRC days, doesn't this a) require routed ports, so anything not a private controlled network is out, b) expose your IP address, which is a security risk, and c) is 1:1 only. It's also more of a side protocol than actually being part of IRC, right? Whereas posting images directly into the chat window and having everyone see it is insanely useful.
- okasaki 8y agoIt does not have full slack-like functionality. But it was never limited to just text. Some of the biggest communities on IRC revolve(d) around file sharing over DCC. Anyway I think saying that it's "insanely" useful is a gross exaggeration. You know what is insanely useful though? Having open source clients and access to logs without paying $100 per year per user.
- misnome 8y agoSo, our small team is using google hangouts but that also supports image pasting (and is searchable, free). Image pasting is for more than just memes. We can post screenshots of errors, or user data/visualisations, or sections of syntax-highlighted code. All of this is infinitely more agile than going through a bulky ticket system (which we also use once we’ve confirmed as bugs or decided how to use forwards). So no, it’s not an exaggeration at all. IRC was fun in the 90s but seems to have stopped there? It was also never ~at all~ friendly for non-technical users, which is a complete non-starter nowadays.
- okasaki 8y agoThe alternative to pasting images is making a ticket? I would have thought it would be uploading images to some image hosting site and then pasting a link.
- zamalek 8y agoDon't forget NickServ. It's a pretty massive user bottleneck. More than half of the people in my (tech) company would probably take more than 20 minutes to figure that out.
- DC-3 8y agoI used to spend a fair bit of time in a non-tech IRC (we've moved to Discord since) and the amount of intelligent people who simply could not get the hang of NickServ was astounding.
- self_awareness 8y agoI've always wondered why IRC clients didn't add seamless integration with NickServs of large networks. Maybe this was one of the reasons why services like Slack or Discord are successful; these services are taking your hand and are guiding you through everything, while IRC expects the user to read RFC and diagnostic server output in order to figure what's going on. I don't think it has to be this way. IRC as a protocol probably can be used to build a service as friendly as Slack. I.e. it's not a problem to add URL autoexpansion, like in this WeeChat plugin: https://github.com/antekone/youtube-autoexpand https://github.com/antekone/youtube-autoexpand . Of course it's not easily possible or practical to show pictures inside of the terminal window, but I think it's entirely possible to create a new modern Slack-competitive IRC client over a pure IRC network. What could be done on IRC can be seen in an old Microsoft app, Microsoft Comic Chat: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Comic_Chat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Comic_Chat . (disclaimer: i prefer IRC to Slack/Discord but I get why for many people IRC is a bad idea)
- jandrese 8y agoNickServ always felt like a terrible hack to me. It doesn't help that some major servers have incredibly stingy limits on NickServ too. I've had usernames age out after only a week, and the registration process is fairly cumbersome. Plus it involves sending a password in plaintext over the network, which never felt good.