3 ms·
I'm glad these guys are working on the problem but I'm sorry this article makes it seem like these guys suddenly discovered this problem. Jim Warren is the rea
by gumby 8y ago
I'm glad these guys are working on the problem but I'm sorry this article makes it seem like these guys suddenly discovered this problem.
Jim Warren is the reason all of the California code was opened up and put online in the 1990s.
Carl Malamud has been working on this for decades, and among other things is the reason SEC filings are all online. He's been working hard on building codes for many years too. His nonprofit is Public.Resource.Org
Another nonprofit, free.law, has several programs to free up other legal resources needed to understand the law.
- Old_Thrashbarg 8y agoUpCodes cofounder here. Fair point, and we definitely don't want to steal any credit from people like Carl Malamud and so many others who have devoted over a decade to this. We're pretty new on the scene and unlike Carl who's an activist and whose main purpose is to protect the rule of law, we kind of stumbled into this lawsuit. We thought we were in the clear! Especially reading the case law, including the Veeck case (fought and lost by SBCCI which later became ICC) and seeing that Carl has most of the ICC materials on his site. We thought at the very least ICC wouldn't be able to relitigate this issue. It's bullshit. Anyway, UpCodes wouldn't exist if it weren't for Carl Malamud, Corynne McSherry and Peter Veeck.
- cabaalis 8y ago(IANAL) Good luck in your case, as it appears there is a government-created monopoly at work. I do believe ICC should own and control the copyrights to their work, however. It seems wrong that local and state governments can both (a) release themselves of their own governing decisions by choosing a sole-sourced third party to write the regulations and (b) allow that third party to control access to the regulations at the same time. However, having myself visited an area in an underdeveloped country which was basically a shantytown, we should all recognize that building codes improve the lives of everyone. The only real outcome that fits my IANAL vision of the law is to break up this monopoly and for local governments adopt and subsequently outline the codes themselves. The business could maybe then become selling those codes as a vendor to the government, but the governments themselves are the ones publishing them to their citizens.
- Gibbon1 8y agoYou could fix this issue by a federal law that says any law or regulation that isn't freely available is unenforceable. Oh your building code is copyrighted and you have to pay to get a copy? Good news! Legally there is no building code.
- phjesusthatguy3 8y agoI'd go the other way and write it into law that the law is uncopywritable.
- rhino369 8y agoThe law is already uncopyrightable. The issue is whether anything incorporated by reference by the law would retroactively remove its copyright. If a court require files be submitted in .docx mean that MS loses copyright on .docx file structure?
- gumby 8y agoThe stuff incorporated by reference has the force of law so should be freely available and resdistributable. What's interesting is metadata: though court decisions themselves are not copyrightable, pagination and such (which is used by the courts to refer to other decisions) is. Disturbingly, when Malamud tried to publish Georgia's state laws he was accused of terrorism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_States#Federal_and_state_laws_are_not_protected_by_copyright https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_St...
- Gibbon1 8y agoOpinion of mine, abuse of terrorism statutes should be a felony.
- jimz 8y agoThe federal government forcing a state to enforce a federal statute would definitely violate the 10th Amendment if the state has laws against that. I think most states have building codes irrespective of copyright status. However, the very scenario is covered generally by statute already. Regulations, even copyrighted ones adopted by an agency, must be publicly accessible to have the force of law. Freely accessible in most cases relate to having physical access to the text in some free way. This seems like something that can be solved very simply on the state level: just redefine publicly accessible to publicly accessible on the internet.
- kemitchell 8y agoIt's vitally important that private business get involved in the issue, as well. I think the activists would say: Give UpCodes as much thunder as possible, and get a good precedent out of it. Other companies, like FastCase, have been there, too.