3 ms·
> Both elections saw the US electing someone against whom the actual majority of voters voted. And with the proposal here we would still end up with the US ele
by yellowapple 8y ago
> Both elections saw the US electing someone against whom the actual majority of voters voted.
And with the proposal here we would still end up with the US electing someone against whom the actual majority of voters voted. This proposal fixes nothing. In fact, it makes things even worse, since - again - the state might very well be actively going against its own voters.
> The only other options would be far heavier overhauls of the voting system
There are plenty of other options that are just as possible:
- Allocating electors by congressional district (this is what Maine and Nebraska already do)
- Allocation electors by electoral district
- Allocating electors proportionally (e.g. if - state-wide - 60% of voters vote for A and 40% vote for B, then 60% of EC electors will vote for A and 40% of EC electors will vote for B)
Proportional allocation of EC votes would be gerrymandering-resistant (since there'd be no creatively-drawn districts involved) and would be a more accurate representation of the will of the people of that state. It would allow, for example, Democrats in otherwise-Republican-dominated states (e.g. Houston v. the rest of Texas) to be represented electorally (and likewise allow the same for Republicans in otherwise-Democrat-dominated states like California). If an actual "fix" for our electoral system is what you seek, then that'd be the best option by pretty much every metric.