7 ms·
Copyright doesnt always mean no-one else has rights to it. The idea of copyrighting a publication of legal statutes or codes could have some good, but the idea
by rolph 8y ago
Copyright doesnt always mean no-one else has rights to it.
The idea of copyrighting a publication of legal statutes or codes could have some good, but the idea of obstructing the publics access to regulations, laws, or codes, and then somwhere down the line this problem goes away in exchange for money, is absolute despotic kruft.
so finacially challenged people have impaired opportunity to understand the law, its already an issue when there are mainly online disseminations of statues, and no physical text in easy reach. The technically challenged people have no access to the text of law in digital form, furthermore there is an issue with privacy that could come about.
No-one should have to Pay, login, sign up or give PII in exchange for access to text of legal statutes, something that is public property and derived from public monies remitted to an elected government acting within its bounds of authority.
- brlewis 8y ago>The idea of copyrighting a publication of legal statutes or codes could have some good No it cannot. Copyright grants things called "exclusive rights". They are called such because, absent copyright, nobody is excluded from them. There is no good whatsoever in hindering people from copying, distributing, publicly performing, or creating derived works from existing laws or regulations. I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish by saying "Copyright doesnt always mean no-one else has rights to it." It's like saying shooting someone's leg doesn't mean you shot their arm. Copyright's sole purpose is to exclude rights from people who would otherwise have them. Pointing out that it doesn't take away all rights doesn't add to the discussion.
- rolph 8y agoif the public owns the legal text under a copyright then some 3rd party cant use that text to make money, and eventually claim it as thier own works, due to formatting, and secretarial time requireing offsetting revenue.
- ABCLAW 8y ago>There is no good whatsoever in hindering people from copying, distributing, publicly performing, or creating derived works from existing laws or regulations. This isn't true. Let's say we decide that our copyright registry requires the submission of a full work to the government for archival purposes so we can compare a given work against the registered copyright. We'd obviously want someone to be able to check the register, but not gain the right to print someone else's registered work for sale commercially. If we didn't have any hindering, we couldn't actually run the registry at all! The discussion here presupposes that all works which relate to regulations or laws do not have any independent value outside of their legal function, which isn't necessarily the case. That said, when it comes to the text of legislation or a building code, your assumptions hold true. Just don't design a policy solution ignoring the other edge cases, though :).
- wyldfire 8y ago> No-one should have to Pay, login, sign up or give PII in exchange for access to text of legal statutes, something that is public property and derived from public monies remitted to an elected government acting within its bounds of authority. So where's the utility in permitting the codes to be copyrighted? How could the public benefit from this?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]