3 ms·
I've run directly into this with regards to the National Electrical Code. As an engineer doing your own home wiring is dead simple, but does require reading the
by mindslight 8y ago
I've run directly into this with regards to the National Electrical Code. As an engineer doing your own home wiring is dead simple, but does require reading the specific practices if you want your work to be "to code", which is a generally good idea for liability reasons and your own safety. Public.resource.org used to have the NEC up, but took it down I think out of prudence/capitulation rather than a hard legal judgment. It's of course still easily available through torrents.
The only sensible model is that in order for a state (or other AHJ) to incorporate a code into law, then it must license it for the purpose of doing so. States would then directly pay code bodies for writing the codes, and could weigh for themselves whether it really makes sense to pay for revisions every 3 years.
Of course the code bodies don't actually want to just do this. What they want to do is the classic rent seeking model of installing their hook into government "for free", and then extracting a toll on each individual user in the form of official code books, prep manuals, etc. But this is directly incompatible with the rule of law, as the case law has been casually demonstrating.
(PS if you want an example of how much sway trade guilds still hold over local governments, check out Ernst Meyer vs Town of Nantucket. It's not about code per se, but about the general right to work on one's own home)
- jimktrains2 8y agoSame exact thing for the HIPAA regulations; they're written by a 3rd party who owns the copyright to them. It's maddening that the government can simply wholesale adopt a code and not make it public. The feds, or at least the states individually, should hire experts to write the codes that are used by the public. Anything else is a travesty.
- repiret 8y agoI think its totally acceptable for the states to adopt codes written by an independent organization, as long as in the end, people subject to the codes can access them without restriction. I think the grandparent is right, the only viable business model is for states to pay a license to incorporate the codes into the law. We'd need to rewrite copyright law somewhat for that to work, because the code-writing agency needs to retain the ability to sell a license to more than one state, and sell a license for updates to the code, and to stop other people from making derivative works and trying to sell those to the states.
- mjevans 8y agoWhat we need is for one of two things to happen: A) Buy out specifications to release to public domain as part of the law. B) Pay government workers / contract outside entities to perform work under the same restrictions as government workers: the results of work becoming public domain.
- Old_Thrashbarg 8y agoMost of the organizations are extremely flush with cash and most of it is not from selling the law. That includes the organization in this article, ICC. The majority of ICC’s revenue comes from program services, including consulting, certification, and training, which do not rely on profiting by limiting access to the law. ICC makes a lot of money. Attempting to copyright the law is unnecessary.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jandrese 8y agoSeems like writing laws for the government should be work for hire. Once it is done the copyright is transferred to the government and then opened to the public. The organization gets paid, everybody is happy.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Same exact thing for the HIPAA regulations; they're written by a 3rd party who owns the copyright to them. That's not actually true: HIPAA regulations are adopted by the federal Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services within the Department of Health and Human Services under statutory authority in HIPAA. However, there are a large number of private IT and other standards that are directly mandated for certain uses under those regulations (and, in many cases, those standards themselves incorporate other private standards.) Some of these standards are free-of-charge, others are not.
- Old_Thrashbarg 8y agoRight, following the fire laws when doing any work at home is not just a good idea, but required for safety of you and others in your vicinity. You can be charged criminally for not following these laws that are behind paywalls. In the ASTM v Public.Resource.Org case, I believe you are right, PRO agreed to voluntarily remove the laws while the case goes on. But that case has been going on since 2013 (https://ia801306.us.archive.org/33/items/gov.uscourts.dcd.161410/gov.uscourts.dcd.161410.docket.html https://ia801306.us.archive.org/33/items/gov.uscourts.dcd.16...). I suspect the law publishers are quite happy to have it drag on for another decade. The NFPA (publisher of NEC) makes over $80M a year, and the CEO is very well paid.
- mindslight 8y agoA worrying alternative outcome could be that codes are copyrighted, posting them is copyright infringement, but that such non-public codes do not carry the force of law. I obviously hope this doesn't happen, but it would be a logically consistent outcome. This would then "shatter" the argument into many impractical state-level lawsuits over judgment calls where an AHJ declared something unsafe because it didn't follow the letter of the code (even though it's not actually law), and non-code-buying individuals would each be left fighting uphill battles to prove their work was safe - effectively the shape of the Meyer reference I posted above.
- ccsys 8y agoI too would interpret and act within an understanding of the law that since our government has paid a licensing fee to UNIDROIT on behalf of the people that the copy written is freely available to each citizen under fair use. Rent seeking corps and their lobbyists are trying to make that difficult by writing a lot of scary cease and desist letters full of hot air.
- massysett 8y agoNFPA grants free online access to the National Electrical Code: https://www.nfpa.org/NEC/About-the-NEC/Free-online-access-to-the-NEC-and-other-electrical-standards https://www.nfpa.org/NEC/About-the-NEC/Free-online-access-to...
- mindslight 8y ago... so goes their argument. Yet for their "free online access", the first thing one is greeted with is a requirement to make an account, presumably entering into a contract, meaning it's not Free. In addition to pegging your CPU because you have to use a javascript browser to view it, terrible navigation controls, and most likely preventing copypasting, and printing. From a practical user-friendliness perspective, I'd really just suggest torrenting the pdf and getting on with your project. If one doesn't actually want to digest dense technical specifications, I'd recommend a practical book distilling the subject down to what's relevant. The local library likely has such books, along with a copy of the full NEC. If you were simply trying to be helpful by pointing out a practical avenue of access, then the following rebuttal isn't directed at you. But from an abstract legal perspective, the whole point is that a private entity should never have the privilege of owning the law, and them being kind and gifting some limited form of access does not change this.
- noughth 8y agoWhile this is technically true, you are expressly forbidden from printing it or saving a local copy. Moreover, they are not made available in a format that is searchable or otherwise conducive to actually finding what you want. In other words, if you want to actually use them without being constantly annoyed, you'll have to pay up.