3 ms·
It's simply not economical to automate every job yet, although that time is fast approaching. Do you not see automation getting cheaper, more reliable and more
by arcticbull 8y ago
It's simply not economical to automate every job yet, although that time is fast approaching. Do you not see automation getting cheaper, more reliable and more accessible in the future? Would you put your own money on that prediction and invest in people-forward manufacturing companies instead of companies like ABB? Regardless of your feelings towards how I presented it or your value judgement or meaning, this change is coming, and we need to prepare. We can pretend it's not and get lapped again by countries that do, or we can lean into it and get there first, build a society around it where people can still create value and meaning even if menial and manual labor is automated.
Products produced by manual labor will be more expensive than ones that aren't. They largely already are. If the US wants to double-down we'll need to tax robots and apply tariffs to artificially raise the cost of goods produced through automation to even out the discrepancies in efficiency. Is that the path we want to go down? Or would you rather face facts and structure a society, take the yoke off the proletariat (haha) and allow all your fellow countrymen to benefit from the gift that is not having to do manual labor? Wanting your fellow man to toil away in a factory to support your lifestyle is the ultimate elitism.
It's like saying we should go back to the slide-rule because there's good jobs in making them, and you get that down home country feeling using one. I'm not going to be putting my money into slide-rules, I'll stick with Intel.
- scarface74 8y agoWill automation get cheaper than paying people basically nothing overseas like the garment manufacturing industry and to a lesser extent the electronics industry - like Foxconn? I’m not arguing for not making progress, but the more we become a digital economy, the more you will have a few fortunate people who work in businesses with 0 marginal costs and make a lot of money and the rest doing the unglamorous poorly paid work.
- arcticbull 8y ago>> Will automation get cheaper than paying people basically nothing overseas like the garment manufacturing industry and to a lesser extent the electronics industry - like Foxconn? (a) Unequivocally, Yes. (b) The cost of manufacturing goods in China is within 5% of the cost to manufacture within the US, the difference is the US has cheaper power and China has cheaper labor. If we remove the labor it will be cheaper to manufacture in the US with machines than China with labor, for instance. I'll try and find the economist article where I got this information from. In fact the promised Foxconn plant in the US was/is going to be almost entirely automated. And why wouldn't it be? >> I’m not arguing for not making progress, but the more we become a digital economy, the more you will have a few fortunate people who work in businesses with 0 marginal costs and make a lot of money and the rest doing the unglamorous poorly paid work. This is a social problem, as I mentioned, and the solution isn't to make the lower classes hammer things all day and root around for shiny rocks. That at best slows down the process, it does nothing to reverse it. The solution is to revisit social contract. It'll be a big change, and it will be worth it.
- scarface74 8y agoIn fact the promised Foxconn plant in the US was/is going to be almost entirely automated. And why wouldn't it be? The Foxconn plant is turning out to be a complete fraud.... https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/29/18027032/foxconn-wisconsin-plant-jobs-deal-subsidy-governor-scott-walker https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/29/18027032/foxconn-wiscons...