6 ms·
The good news is even if you see limited value in "liberal arts" the total value in the system will be higher, as automation retains or increases the existing v
by arcticbull 8y ago
The good news is even if you see limited value in "liberal arts" the total value in the system will be higher, as automation retains or increases the existing value, and the displaced/retrained workers produce yet more value even if I accept the premise that it's limited.
>> If all jobs could be automated more cheaply than humans, don't you think they would have done it?
Not everything that's possible has become economical yet. This is kind of the definition of progress :) If all cancer could be cured, don't you think they would have done it by now?
- scarface74 8y agoThe good news is even if you see limited value in "liberal arts" the total value in the system will be higher, as automation retains or increases the existing value, and the displaced/retrained workers produce yet more value even if I accept the premise that it's limited. That was sound economic theory somewhat before the digital age and zero marginal cost. Before, to make more of x you needed more people, input goods, etc. But, when it comes to digital goods the cost of producing more of $x is 0. The fixed cost to produce Windows for example is high but the marginal cost to license Windows to a manufacturer is 0. No matter how many copies of Windows MS sells, they don’t need to hire more people. There has never been a point in history where 10 people could produce a $1 billion dollar product like Instagram. This can't help but to lead to a wider gap between the haves and have nots.
- arcticbull 8y agoSorry, maybe there's some misunderstanding. I'm saying that the total value of all goods and services produced by humans today will remain at least as big once you replace the people with robots. This frees up the people to do whatever they want, creating additional marginal value. The sum total of value of (humans) is < (humans + robots). It's probably strictly speaking, double, although I was allowing some wiggle room because of your value system (not judging, just trying to meet you on your turf). Narrowing the gap between the haves and the have nots is something I'm incredibly passionate about too. However, the way to do that IMO isn't by making the have-nots hit things with a hammer in a factory or root around in the ground for shiny rocks while longing for the good old days. It's going to take real social reform and hard work.
- scarface74 8y agoI'm saying that if it use to take 10 people to create 100 widgets that people want every time that you wanted to produce 100 more widgets you needed 10 more people. With digital, 10 people can produce 100 virtual widgets, 1000, 10,000 or 10,000,000. Those 10 people are going to get rich (i.e. FAANG software developers) while a lot of people are not going to have anything productive to do where they can make money. You could say the same about manufacturing.
- arcticbull 8y ago"Those 10 people are going to get rich" is true unless we face facts and change social contract.
- scarface74 8y agoI’m a big social safety net type of guy that believes in helping people who either can’t help themselves or are in a temporary predicament. But what do you propose when there are more structural issues where there just aren’t enough jobs to go around?
- arcticbull 8y agoHistory shows the more developed a society (specifically correlated to education and income) the lower its birth rate [1]. Japan is a great example, their population is shrinking (1.44 births per woman vs. a replacement rate of 2.1) although the correlation is universal. Automation leads to development which leads to declining population. IMO the answer is basic income until the population naturally right-sizes, followed by a balance of immigration with social policy either encouraging or discouraging raising children as appropriate. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4255510/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4255510/