5 ms·
> Nobody should do factory jobs... This is a terrible attitude. Many blue collar jobs are perfectly good well paying careers available without crushing studen
by BurningFrog 8y ago
> Nobody should do factory jobs...
This is a terrible attitude.
Many blue collar jobs are perfectly good well paying careers available without crushing student debt to people who (crazy, I know) don't want to sit by a desk all day.
- arcticbull 8y agoI'm not saying these people have to take on desk jobs, I'm more of a basic income person myself. Instead of "hit X with hammer, place X in bin, repeat until retired" I suggest we find meaningful jobs for these people either in technical roles, small-businesses, liberal arts or whatever it is they want to pursue to create meaning in their lives. Robots will do the job better, they won't get tired, they won't get sick and they don't need meaning. These jobs aren't coming back, the sooner we face facts and work through it the better off we'll be in the economy of the future.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoIt's not 1919. Nobody is making their employees do the same repetitive labor in the same setting day in and day out. That's how you burn our workers. You can only get away with that in industries where they'd burn out regardless for some other reason. Modern factory jobs are no worse than the other jobs of about the same skill requirements and pay.
- all2 8y ago> Nobody is making their employees do the same repetitive labor in the same setting day in and day out. Do you not know anyone that works in a factory? Spend some time in the South, or in the Midwest. You'll find people who do the same thing day-in and day-out. Those jobs still exist.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI've worked those kind of jobs. You rotate from station to station for each shift/time slot. It's really no worse than working in an institutional kitchen for the same length of time (and the pay is typically better). I get that people in ivory towers will decry it all as horrible but the fact of the matter is that none of those jobs are any better or worse than the other once you account for people's variable preferences. I'd personally rather do outdoor labor of some sort but some people prefer the air conditioned factory floor.
- scruple 8y agoThat isn't my experience at all in a glass plant in the midwest. If you were a run of the mill laborer on the floor, you had a station and you worked your 8/12/16 hour shift right there the entire time. I stood at the end of a long cooling belt inspecting glass for QA defects, piece by miserable piece until I was able to clock out. edit/ Also, throwing boxes for delivery companies or warehouses, you'll be standing at the end of your belt filling up trucks for the entire duration of your 8/12/16 hour shift.
- Loughla 8y ago>Nobody is making their employees do the same repetitive labor in the same setting day in and day out. That's just not true. Come to flyover country. There are many, many jobs that are 'stick metal piece in here remove stamped metal piece there' sorts of work.
- TecoAndJix 8y agoAbout a decade ago, i worked in a factory that produced eggs for things like McMuffins. For 8 hours a night I would make stacks of 10 or so of these paddies coming down a conveyor belt and place them in a cardboard box. After several stacks the box would be full and you pushed it down a roller to go get sealed and shipped. This is ALL i did. I stacked paddies in a box and then pushed the box. I had some really elaborate day-dreaming scenarios that maintained my sanity. Lots of the people working there had 10+ years with the company doing similar mindless tasks - they are still around!
- smileysteve 8y agoSadly, I know a lot of college educated people who describe their white collar jobs as finding a related document, scanning it, and entering the data into the right place in a spreadsheet.
- arcticbull 8y agoIf that is indeed accurate, a lot of their jobs will be automated too. Few roles are truly 'safe' but the ones I'd write a script to solve are definitely less so.
- scarface74 8y ago"We need meaningful jobs like liberal arts instead of factory work..." is the most elitist sentiment I've read on HN in a while. And that's saying a lot...
- arcticbull 8y agoWould you consider a job where you perform a repetitive physical task, potentially risky, with the same input and the same output better suited to a human or to a machine? Which do you think could do the job better? If you had a job copy numbers from one spreadsheet into another spreadsheet, would you not write a script? Which do you think would do a better job? It's not elitist, it's pragmatic. There are definitely jobs that require physical labor that provide meaningful value at the moment, though the days are numbered there too. Japan developed a fully-automated farm. [1] We shouldn't keep them around just because we don't have something better for the workers to do. It's our social obligation to find them something better to do. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/feb/01/japanese-firm-to-open-worlds-first-robot-run-farm https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/feb/01/japanese...
- scarface74 8y agoIt might surprise you, but some people actually prefer factory work, construction, and manual labor over sitting behind a desk. But I definitely see more value in the jobs you demean than the "liberal arts". If all jobs could be automated more cheaply than humans, don't you think they would have done it? There is nothing pragmatic about a liberal arts degree in Ancient Chinese Art History....
- arcticbull 8y agoThe good news is even if you see limited value in "liberal arts" the total value in the system will be higher, as automation retains or increases the existing value, and the displaced/retrained workers produce yet more value even if I accept the premise that it's limited. >> If all jobs could be automated more cheaply than humans, don't you think they would have done it? Not everything that's possible has become economical yet. This is kind of the definition of progress :) If all cancer could be cured, don't you think they would have done it by now?
- tombert 8y agoSure, but if a machine can do something cheaper and safer, we shouldn't have humans be doing that work. The people who were doing this dangerous work could be more-efficiently used somewhere that hasn't been automated yet.
- smileysteve 8y agoWow, you took that way out of context.