2 ms·
Yes, the US really values the middleman. There is something to be said for it, since middlemen can compete and innovate. In computer science, this is called ind
by EGreg 8y ago
Yes, the US really values the middleman. There is something to be said for it, since middlemen can compete and innovate. In computer science, this is called indirection — it provides more flexibility and without it, you have one-size-fits-all solutions. In the real world, you have for example Uber/Amazon/Apple /Google/Facebook squeezing providers, due to their monopoly powers.
What happens in the real world is that the doctors aggregate (AMA, ADA) and then the patients aggregate (insurance companies) but it never quite gets to a complete single buyer/payer on both sides without government action.
There is also the argument for how many jobs will be lost in X industry if we replace it with a more efficient solution. Here is a recent video of a famous paleoconservative debating it with a famous neoconservative in the US: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YFMcq0Vzsb4 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YFMcq0Vzsb4
Usually the solution is social democracy - letting the private markets operate but having the government run a single payer system for the basic level of service so sellers compete and buyer’s don’t, and everyone is entitled to the basic level.
Single payer can achieve far lower prices, as can eliminating IP protection. But after a while this may have a deleterious effect on R&D (unless you eliminate the IP protection).