4 ms·

To this poster, and the above edit - I live and work in HK, and was in Hong Kong during the protests. There are incredibly distinct Hong Kong foods. You'll nev

by kweks 8y ago

To this poster, and the above edit - I live and work in HK, and was in Hong Kong during the protests. There are incredibly distinct Hong Kong foods. You'll never find yuanyang (tea coffee mix) in mainland,like you'll not find Rua Jia Mu (Chinese snack burger) in Hong Kong. Obviously HKers have Cantonese roots. I wasn't arguing who was more traditional, I was pointing out that HKers consider themselves Hong Kongese, not Chinese. The OP alludes that HK was kept under the yolk of British rule, and is eager to shed its shackles to return to the mainland. This is simply not the case.

ElBarto 8y ago
This is like saying that a regional dish in the US isn't "American"... China is a vast place and has a multitude of local flavours and dishes. This does not mean that HK isn't Chinese.
EastToWest 8y ago
I can assure you there are incredibly distinct foods, languages and cultures everywhere in China. People from different provinces consider themselves "people from that particular province". I guess the difference is that they also consider themselves Chinese. > The OP alludes that HK was kept under the yolk [sic] of British rule, and is eager to shed its shackles to return to the mainland. This is simply not the case. But they were. Governers were appointed by the Queen. Protests were brutally surpressed -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong_1966_riots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong_1966_riots (edit: typos)
NotPaidToPost 8y ago
China is a vast place, of course there are local dishes. But no-one would seriously even suggest that HK's food isn't Chinese food, or that their culture isn't Chinese. > The OP alludes that HK was kept under the yolk of British rule, and is eager to shed its shackles to return to the mainland. This is simply not the case. I cannot find any such allusion in this thread. It is true, though that the situation wasn't better under the British, and it was perhaps worse (no LegCo).

by kweks 8y ago

ElBarto 8y ago

This is like saying that a regional dish in the US isn't "American"... China is a vast place and has a multitude of local flavours and dishes. This does not mean that HK isn't Chinese.

EastToWest 8y ago

I can assure you there are incredibly distinct foods, languages and cultures everywhere in China. People from different provinces consider themselves "people from that particular province". I guess the difference is that they also consider themselves Chinese. > The OP alludes that HK was kept under the yolk [sic] of British rule, and is eager to shed its shackles to return to the mainland. This is simply not the case. But they were. Governers were appointed by the Queen. Protests were brutally surpressed -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong_1966_riots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong_1966_riots (edit: typos)

NotPaidToPost 8y ago

China is a vast place, of course there are local dishes. But no-one would seriously even suggest that HK's food isn't Chinese food, or that their culture isn't Chinese. > The OP alludes that HK was kept under the yolk of British rule, and is eager to shed its shackles to return to the mainland. This is simply not the case. I cannot find any such allusion in this thread. It is true, though that the situation wasn't better under the British, and it was perhaps worse (no LegCo).