5 ms·
To be honest I'm not sure what difference it would have made. They're too close to the mainland geographically. At best it'd be a Taiwan Jr. (with Beijing asser
by arcticbull 8y ago
To be honest I'm not sure what difference it would have made. They're too close to the mainland geographically. At best it'd be a Taiwan Jr. (with Beijing asserting outright ownership and refusing to recognize independence while being in a position to do something about it physically), and at worst, well, let's just say there wouldn't have been 50 years of freedom.
- devoply 8y agoPut a hundred nukes and a few military bases and tell China to f-off. In fact that's what we should be doing in Taiwan right now. It's stupid to let this sort of government which to me closely resembles fascism do whatever it wants.
- golergka 8y agoSo, increase DoD spending even more (in such a way that cannot be easily reverted) and further antagonize with second most influential country on Earth which is really important to US economically - while confirming that all any small country needs to get free american help is to peddle a small democratic underdog narrative? Just to be clear - in Hong Kong case, I believe this narrative to be true, but it being true is much less important that it being perceived as true and actively promoted in american media.
- devoply 8y agoThis should be a global effort funded by democratic countries including the EU, North America, Britain, and maybe even India. The point is to keep the world from fracturing into hands of this sort of pseudo-fascism and capitalist-liberalism. The more I see the sorts of moves China is making, the more I feel that we're heading into a new sort of Cold War and America seems to be sitting back letting it happen rather than actively attempting to contain it... because it seems that they can't actually afford to do so.
- golergka 8y agoThat was the intent behind UN and League of Nations before that. Any new similar thing like will end up just like that - a beurocratic monstrosity that lacks any moral authority and is used as a pawn in realpolitik games.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jenshk 8y agoHong Kong, at least, is Chinese and always have been. The British leased the New Territories(90% of Hong Kong) from the Qing Dynasty. Hong Kong island is the only colonial possession, but it's too small to even fit an airport. So the Brits gave it up.
- nailer 8y ago> Hong Kong, at least, is Chinese and always have been That doesn't mean anything. Does it belong to the Chinese in the Communist party? Or the Chinese that live in Hong Kong?
- unchocked 8y agoYou’re thinking Democratically. Geopolitically, HK belongs to China, the historically established state of which Beijing is the capital.
- nailer 8y agoSo do you think Hong Kong 'belonged to Japan' when that was the realpolitik? Beijing might control HK now, but by acknowledging the tyrant's claim, we give them power. Beijing is the capital of the PRC, not 'China'. There are many Chinas, the PRC does not have a monopoly on the name. Hong Kong belongs to it's people.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- computerfriend 8y agoThat's not true, Kowloon was a colonial possession not under lease.
- afarrell 8y agoThe Sino-British Joint declaration was in 1984, when we needed the Sino-Soviet split in order to pressure the USSR.
- lvturner 8y agoThat worked so well in Korea...
- Mirioron 8y agoWorks for the South Koreans.
- arcticbull 8y agoAs it did for the people of Hong Kong. At the time of the handover it represented 20% of China's GDP. Today it's just 2.9%, although that's 5X per capita.
- _cerv 8y agoIn an alternate world where the New Territories had their lease renewed, they probably would remained semi autonomous and any kind of full on independence would agitate China. I don't think they would have sought to isolate other nations over recognizing HK as PRC territory as the UK wields a bit of weight, but you probably would have seen some measures put forth that would have at least required private entities operating in China to treat HK as an extension of Chinese territory, much like what goes on today with Taiwan.