6 ms·
You are no longer free to move around the country
- artmageddon 16y agoI honestly don't think I could live in this country if this sort of thing became the norm for bus and rail travel. I take the train every day to work, each way and back, and given the crowding and delays, it would be so infeasible to have this sort of security theatre when no such threat to these transit systems exist.
- durin42 16y agoI heard the same thing said about the atrocious security theatre at airports, especially the really busy ones like O'Hare. It was going to be temporary, I heard, because there was no practical way it could be permanent. It's been 9 years. Feels pretty permanent to me, as much as I wish that it didn't. I'm afraid at this point the question is whether we're too late with our outrage (or perhaps if the present outrage is sufficient, which it probably won't be.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sudonim 16y agoI've already been opting out of flying. If these checkpoints were everywhere, i'd opt out of citizenship.
- billmcneale 16y ago> If these checkpoints were everywhere, i'd opt out of citizenship. Bullshit.
- prawn 16y agoThat might be abrasive, but it's realistic. These changes (as always) will come gradually so that each increment is not quite so bad as to spark riots, but when viewed as a batch change over 30-50 years will be something amazing. Scanners will be the norm for all public transport, possibly private transport and potentially many public spaces over the coming decades.
- waterlesscloud 16y agoIf you think the naked picture machines are going to be limited to airports, you're just not paying attention.
- dholowiski 16y agoI've said it before- take a train, bus, or don't visit (or live in) the USA. Well, looks like the last option will soon be the only one. I'll say it again- Americans, fix your government. The rest of the world is laughing at you. (and again, yes it's a nervous laugh. You scare us a bit too).
- jonursenbach 16y agoWe're trying to fix it, problem is that the people who actually make decisions are more powerful than we all thought.
- xiaoma 16y agoJust "fix it"? Care to elaborate on how ordinary citizens can pull that off?
- smackfu 16y agoRacism! Just fix it!
- alexgartrell 16y agoNever underestimate American zeal for non-public transportation. edit: some biographical information might clarify this comment. I'm a 21 year old male from the midwest and budding car enthusiast. Additionally, I have a thing from making tongue-in-cheek comments that are absolutely non-obvious to everyone besides myself :)
- wyclif 16y agoI'm sorry, but even though I'm an American (or USAian, if you prefer) and support public transportation, wish it was better and more widespread, &c.-- it's simply shortsighted and simplistic to ascribe it to zeal for private ownership of automobiles. Although enjoyment of the private auto is a distinctly American and capitalist thing, the fact is that it's drastically less expensive and challenging to leverage public transportation in Europe, which is a much smaller land mass.
- joshes 16y agoI'm quickly becoming disturbed with what is happening in the US. I was reading the last few chapters of 1984 last night, for fun, and with what has been happening in the past few months, particularly with the TSA, I am starting to feel as though we are headed toward an Orwellian future. I really do not want to be unnecessarily inciting, but these incremental changes that are occurring are becoming more unsettling as time passes.
- mcantelon 16y agoAbsolutely. The state isn't expending all this energy (the development of the DHS, warrantless wiretapping infrastructure, etc.) for no purpose. The purpose is likely counter-insurgency, not terrorism.
- jacquesm 16y agoIn the Netherlands your only option to move around 'untracked' is to use a bike or to walk, any other mode of transportation is monitored. And better leave your cell phone at home because telcos are required by law to keep location information for quite a long period.
- egor83 16y ago> any other mode of transportation is monitored Could you please elaborate? You don't have to show your ID or to be checked to board a train/bus. The police are present at railway/bus stations, but I think it's the case in any other country in the world.
- timknauf 16y agoAny other country? Police certainly aren't stationed at railway and bus stations here in New Zealand.
- stretchwithme 16y agoI don't care about monitoring, if that's just having my picture being taken. Anyone can take my picture when I go out already. But having my person scanned or groped or fingered is another matter entirely. And it does violate the fourth amendment which protects us from warrantless searches.
- _delirium 16y agoI'm not sure where I stand on it, but I do see a qualitative difference if the government were routinely using cameras in public areas with facial-recognition software to track people's movements around town, versus just using the cameras as security cameras. Given good enough computer vision, and ubiquitous enough cameras, the end effect can be very similar in tracking effect to the government being able to attach a GPS device to you. It's true that it's all pieced together out of snapshots that would individually be unobjectionable (someone taking a photo of me in a public place), but the end result seems rather different. If a private party attempted to do it, we'd normally consider it a form of harassment, and it'd be illegal in a lot of jurisdictions. You can photograph someone in a public area, but you can't hire an army of photographers to photograph them all around town as they go about their daily routine and plot their movements on a map, because that'd be weird/objectionable.
- garply 16y agoLet's say that we had machine vision software good enough to not need a human to look at the scanner images unless it discovered undesirable objects on the person (I don't think that's so far fetched technologically). What percent of people who currently oppose these machines would do so if they were completely automated? Personally, I still would, as I am more concerned about the government scanning me and finding other things that it finds undesirable. I have no intention of blowing stuff up, but if these things become widespread, I think they might well be used to search for things other than weapons. Constantly being searched for illegal objects when I go out in public would disturb me. That's why I don't like these things. But I bet most of the people are just opposed because of the naked pictures.
- grinich 16y agoI don't have a problem with the scanners. I have a problem with: • Inconclusive reporting about the health effects. • Conflict of interest with Deepak Chopra. • Inconsistent attitude and treatment by TSA officials • Firm statements that the machines do not store images, and then stories about images being saved. • Policies such as banning TSA employees from wearing radiation measurement badges. • Threats of $10k "civil lawsuit" • Pat-downs for children. • etc, etc. The scanners are not the problem. The problem is the TSA.
- kingnothing 16y agoThis is not hacker news. Leave it on reddit.
- stretchwithme 16y agoWhen only the state is free to do what it wants, only the state will hack.
- iwr 16y agoSince when has legality had to matter for hackers when hacking?
- stretchwithme 16y agoi speak of freedom, not legality. If the gulag awaits you if you're caught, that's a completely different story than it would be if you hack in a society governed by rule of law. But don't take my word for it. Ask the North Korean hackers.
- stretchwithme 16y agoThe Fourth Amendment to the Constitution explicitly protects the people from unreasonable searches. "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." One might say that you submit to this as part of the deal to get on the plane. But if that were true, it would be between you and the airline, not the government. That means it really should be the airlines that decide how intrusive searches should be. And you would be free to choose an airline whose policies you agree with. And the airline would be free to reject you as a passenger. The government has hijacked the relationship between you and the people you've hired to get you from point A to point B. Just because of previous lapses in their intelligence efforts enabled some people to do something terrible doesn't mean you lose your rights.
- gst 16y agoThe Fourth Amendment only protects you if you aren't inside the "constitution free zone". And as it happens, about two thirds of the US population live within this zone. See: http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty/are-you-living-constitution-free-zone http://www.aclu.org/national-security_technology-and-liberty... and http://yro.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=08/10/24/197215 http://yro.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=08/10/24/197215
- stretchwithme 16y agoFrightening. They've officially run amok. The only good news in all of this is that it won't be too long before they've consumed every available resource and will have to cut back on the drugs that are making them act this way.
- smackfu 16y agoNot particularly relevant, since that's not the justification they are using for the TSA.
- prawn 16y ago