4 ms·
It's nothing to do with monopolies. It's just that it's an unworkable idea. The worst a website can do is trick the user into downloading something. The worst
by threeseed 8y ago
It's nothing to do with monopolies. It's just that it's an unworkable idea.
The worst a website can do is trick the user into downloading something. The worst an app can do is steal their data, capture video from their mic/camera, wipe their computer, turn it into a DDOS bot etc. It's night and day.
And so trusting third party certificate issuers who currently don't verify websites or their owners and having them now certify apps is a pretty big leap.
- kbenson 8y agoYou misunderstood what I was suggesting. I'm not saying existing certificate authorities should sign apps, but that allowing a trusted authority to sign and distribute apps that a user could opt in to would be beneficial. Think yum/apt repo signing keys, and how if you add a third party repo you can require the public key signatures to match, except tied into the OS much closer. I used the CA analogy because vastly more people are familiar with that than the intricacies of open source package management for a few distros.
- scarface74 8y agoWe already see how slimy so called trusted businesses are like Google and Facebook are by convincing users to install privacy invasive apps using the enterprise developer program. Who are users suppose to trust? Back in the day users also trusted SourceForge....
- dwaite 8y agoEven technical users have a limited capacity to properly vet what an authority should be allowed to do. Not to mention, this becomes a very heavy-handed choice to the user (as people already see on android), like "either allow this new app version to now root your phone, or you can't use this service at all" The reason we can trust the CA certificates loaded in our browsers have proper processes and operate transparently is that the browser makers leverage those certificates being preloaded as bargaining power. Would we have the opportunity to retain that sort of power in this decentralized world? Or do we start seeing the "essential" apps move out of the store and doing things like background monitoring of the user?
- wolfgke 8y ago> And so trusting third party certificate issuers who currently don't verify websites or their owners and having them now certify apps is a pretty big leap. That is why you should only do this if you are aware of the consequences.
- markovbot 8y agoHow do you prevent a user who is not aware of the consequences but following directions from something they trust from doing it?
- kbenson 8y agoYou put lots of warnings in front, and if after all that they trust the source of the directions, who are we to say otherwise? There's a lot of hubris in assuming we always know better than the user. It may be that in a decade or two people will be a but more knowledgeable about their devices, but I'm afraid we're moving down a path that will make that knowledge mostly useless, since there's now way to express it. We're at an inflection where in the future we will either retain some control over our devices, or almost none. I'm done arguing for complete control, that's boat seems to have sailed. I'm just trying to influence people to not throw away all their control at this point.
- threeseed 8y agoAnd you're ignoring the entire history of computing. Which is that even incredibly smart, incredibly technical users will still click on random dialog boxes and open phishing emails. I understand where you're coming from but I wouldn't bet on a future where users are going to be somehow smarter about this sort of thing.
- kbenson 8y agoI'm not ignoring it, I just value freedom more. It's easy to make an almost perfectly safe society if we're all willing to give up on fundamental freedoms. I think the best solution preserves some core freedoms while making risky behavior harder. Between desktops and phones we've swung between two wildly different paradigms in the last couple decades. I don't think a bit of moderation on both ends (which is already happening with the OS as we see here) is a bad thing. But so far it seems mostly to be going one direction.