5 ms·
Wow, a judge that understands that new technology shouldn't destroy 200+ years of freedom. Here's how I determine whether or not I should be able to mod someth
by jrockway 16y ago
Wow, a judge that understands that new technology shouldn't destroy 200+ years of freedom.
Here's how I determine whether or not I should be able to mod something. Would it be OK for me to smash to device to bits with a big fucking hammer? If so, I feel it's also OK to use a soldering iron to make it read non-special discs, too. Can you play pirated games with that mod? Yup. But consider this: it's legal to own a handgun, and even in unmodified form, you can use that gun to kill as many people as you want. Kill. Take away their life. Forever. And society is fine with people owning those, because they know that if someone kills as many people as they want to (and that number is more than 0), they will be brought to justice. It's worth letting that one psycho have a gun if it means everyone else can hunt animals or protect their families; that's what society has decided. Similarly, people should always be free to tinker with their devices (and even other people's devices, with those people's permission) because the potential positive value to society (a cheap workstation for elementary school computer labs) outweighs the potential negative value to society (someone playing Kill Zombies XXXIV without paying MegaGameCorp $85). Mod chips don't kill game companies, people do.
(Don't get me started on why the government thinks it's OK to put people in prison for growing certain plants in their own homes. I think it must be because some politician had a long talk with God, and God says he hates it when people enjoy themselves. Since God does exist and does talk to people on a regular basis, this sort of makes sense. But I digress...)
- ShabbyDoo 16y agoAs a small-L libertarian, I have no issue with Microsoft offering to me voluntary entry into a licensing agreement for use of an xBox with the restriction that I not modify it. And, any supposed violation of this agreement would, as with most (all?) contractual issues, be civil rather than criminal matter.
- jrockway 16y agoAs a person-that-likes-to-walk-around-his-house-naked, I do not want a company to be able to come in to my house at any time to make sure I'm not violating any rules. Also, that contract would not apply in this case. Sure, the owner is violating the contract, but the person adding the mod chip isn't. He never signed anything.
- chopsueyar 16y agoDon't buy a Kinect.
- elblanco 16y ago> As a person-that-likes-to-walk-around-his-house-naked, I do not want a company to be able to come in to my house at any time to make sure I'm not violating any rules. I wonder if the TSA is going to be handed enforcement of anti-mod-chip laws at some point.
- VMG 16y agoas another small-l libertarian I fully agree with you
- meric 16y agoYeah but currently the XBox isn't licensed to you; You own it, unless I was ill informed.
- enjo 16y agoThe whole idea of licensing a physical product is comical. It always comes down to "who fixes it if it breaks"? If the answer is "me" then I own it and can do whatever the hell I feel like with it.
- chopsueyar 16y agoLike this? http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1946151 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1946151
- enjo 16y agoYa... exactly that really. After all, if I rent a car and it breaks I'm not the one fixing it:)
- ShabbyDoo 16y ago"It always comes down to 'who fixes it if it breaks'?" While this might be an interesting personal test, I don't believe it a legal standard. It is the case that one may enter into a contract to possess a physical good with limitations on its use, right? Isn't the issue that, sans such a contract, the US legal systems applies a common set of rules surrounding ownership?
- iwr 16y agoEven in such a case, breaking the contract would make you subject to tort, rather than criminal law. Meaning you'd have to pay some form of compensation (which would have to be expressly specified in the contract), but not go to prison.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]