3 ms·
Reading things like this, I wonder if there's actually a shortage of ethical understanding, that is, that people who do unethical things simply don't know that
by luckylion 8y ago
Reading things like this, I wonder if there's actually a shortage of ethical understanding, that is, that people who do unethical things simply don't know that what they're doing isn't okay, that they perhaps never even had a thought occur in that direction. That could be solved by teaching everybody about ethics.
My guess is that this isn't the case. People know that what they're doing isn't ethical, but they are doing it nevertheless because it gives them money, power, status, their desired partner etc. You can't prevent that by teaching them about ethics.
- 0815test 8y agoTeaching ethics doesn't really make people more ethical. Rather, ethics flows from self-actualization as a responsible human being (what used to be called dignity) and self-training (whether intentional or not) in making ethically-meaningful choices. So, if you want to "teach ethics", including as it relates to open source, you could encourage folks to read the CatB series http://www.catb.org/esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/ http://www.catb.org/esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/ and point out what that might imply about the ethical implications of FLOSS. But going further than that would probably be useless.
- closeparen 8y agoOne can also understand that you think certain practices are unethical, and disagree.
- luckylion 8y agoSure, I'm not claiming to be an authority on ethics here. It's just my experience that people aren't unsure of what's ethical and what's not, they just ignore their knowledge about ethics because it gets them what they want. That cannot be solved by making them more aware of ethics - they already are aware. Telling a pyromaniac about the dangers of accidentally setting a building on fire won't make him not start fires.
- closeparen 8y agoIt is not hard to find proprietary software developers who routinely query user data for debugging and product analytics. I’ll posit that almost none of them find this inherently unethical, though they probably understand that Stallman does. There are of course some bright lines, like looking up people you personally know, which norms and security auditing heavily deter. But the general concept? Not at all. The HN consensus is not the industry consensus. I mean look at the Hadoop community. What do you think is in those warehouses? The weather? No. Records of user interactions.