3 ms·
> Copyright claims are super easy to make at scale, but the platforms themselves cannot investigate at scale, meaning the small guy suffers. They don't have to
by tzs 8y ago
> Copyright claims are super easy to make at scale, but the platforms themselves cannot investigate at scale, meaning the small guy suffers.
They don't have to investigate. They could simply follow the procedure given in the DMCA.
1. Rights holder sends a notice claiming infringement and meeting the various requirements for such a notice given in the DMCA.
2. The service provider removes the material and promptly notifies the user who put the material up.
3. The user can file a counter notice, disputing that the material infringes.
4. The service provider passes the counter notice back to the rights holder. If the rights holder does not file an infringement lawsuit against the user within 14 days, the service provider puts the material back up.
If they do this, this gets the service provider off the hook for liability to the rights holder if it turns out that the work infringes, and it gets them off the hook for any liability to the user if it turns out that the work does not infringe.
A rights holder could send notices for ridiculous things, like things that are obviously fair use, but unless they are willing to actually go to court they will just get counter notices for most and the material will go back up.
The sites that have implemented their own systems that take down upon any claim and make it hard or impossible for the poster to dispute this are going way beyond what the law requires them to do.
- Mirioron 8y agoEven if they go back up again it still requires a lot of effort to counter notice it, because it requires a human to do so. The claim is lobbed by an algorithm though. There need to be severe consequences for claiming everything.